Reviews for Rustic Tavern in Carlisle, PA
Steaks and pork chops were best we?ve had! The pork chop was absolutely the best we?ve ever had! Very tender and cooked to... perfection. The Delmonico steak was tender, juicy and cooked exactly as ordered. They don?t put much seasoning on the meat andthe meat?s natural flavor holds its own!! The scallops were cooked well and served in garlic and old bay melted butter. Theonly con for this place is it smelled strong of the cleaning agents they use. The odor was off-putting as you enter until yournose acclimates to the smell. Otherwise, good place to go when in town. Read more
Our first time visiting Rustic Tavern for a weeknight dinner was a very good experience. Ample off-street parking. We were... seated in the enclosed patio, which was perfect for our party of five to catch up. The special was a Chicken Oscar, not oneperfectly grilled chicken breast, but two. A nice surprise, and lunch for the next day! I ordered the Grapefruit Crush, andfound it dangerously smooth and refreshing. Any future Grapefruit Crushes will be compared to the one I enjoyed at the RusticTavern! The Waitstaff was amazing, thorough and absolutely engaging. Read more
Good basic restaurant but nothing special. Crab cakes were good. Filet Mignon was Choice not Prime but cooked perfectly. Onion... rings were very good. Cocktails were OK. Ambiance was fair. Service was good. Food arrived quickly. Basically a steak andseafood place with pasta options also. Read more
The kids spaghetti is sour an the adult ribs are rubber, onion rings okay so you get 1 star for them because the shrimp an... scallop kabob Way over spiced "heart burn" an chicken Alfredo - there was no Chicken an it's bland , hard briskets bad bardrinks All sour mash Not top shelf. Definitely a dive. The waitress couldn't even give a recommendation for what to actually try,my guess because it was All ???? Bad an Sad food. Read more
The best steaks and seafood on the West Shore. Extensive menu, cozy rustic atmosphere, great bar, and plenty of formal dining.... This place never disappoints and the staff is great! Read more
An great experience! Waitress was amazing as well as food and cocktails!! Will definitely be back to try other items on the... menu! Read more
I really liked the place. Great food, and very nice people. This lady welcomed me and it felt very nice to visit and have dinner... last night. Highly recommended and will definitely visit again next time I'm in town. Read more
We are from out of town and after reviewing Google, this felt like the best option for lunch. We were not at all disappointed.... The food was delicious. The service was exceptional. We will definitely stop in again when we?re in the area!! Read more