Reviews for Reno's Pizzeria & Ristorante in Carlinville, IL

Love their buffet and everyone was so friendly. Nice selection of pizza and a great salad option.

The pizza & cheesy bread sticks were delicious. The lost star was for the waiter assuming I wouldn't want my change. Although... I complimented his confidence & said keep it, a 50% tip was excessive. Read more

Not many people inside eating, but great food. I had the beef tort with a salad buffet. Wife had lasagna and her niece had a... small special pizza. Everything was delicious and our server was the best. Deffinalty stop here again, I know we will when wecome to town. Read more

Solid place. Incredibly good food for the price, good music, nice atmosphere. That's about all I have to say really. Just a... nice place. Read more

Delicious food - we had pizzas, pastas, & fries + amazing & fast service!

Great for a small town square! Interior not as nice as exterior, but food is excellent. Our server may have been new,... definitely young & a bit timid... Sorry. Bottom line... I highly recommend anyone in the area or traveling Rte 66 check itout! There are probably no 5-stars between the Springfield, IL & St. Louis, MO metro areas.(?) Read more

My family has been ordering pizza from here for probably 8 or 9 years. It is always delicious. I would recommend the Sicilian... stuffed pizza or the BLT pizza. This restaurant is definitely a favorite when my family wants pizza for dinner. Read more

The pizza was really good and they have some great specials. We really enjoyed looking around on the walls. My kids did as well.