Reviews for Little Italy's Pizza in Carlinville, IL
They will not pick up the phone to order pizza
Walked in 30 minutes before closing time. Said they were closed, I said sign says 8:30. Told me they were closed. Well guess... what, I?ll take my business elsewhere. To bad cause I was going to spend some money. Guess they have enough and don?t need mine.Bad business model to turn away customers before posted closing time. Read more
Food is good, but they messed our order up, told us to eat the pizza that was a mistake, and then asked for it back when they... delivered what we actually ordered. Read more
Different prices then what google says. search pizza near me and pulled up website and called them, wouldn't give me the price... that it says on Google for how much ther pizzas are. For example on google it says a 1 topping pizza is $11.47, which in realityits $17.47. I think that's a big difference. Read more
What I like about Little Italy's: the pizza magnets are a great deal, and the prices are definitely affordable. I've never had... bad service here either. However, the cheese quality has definitely decreased over the years. It tastes plastic? But you knowwhat they say: you get what you pay for. Read more
Food is good when you get to order. I called from 8:25 pm till finally at 8:45 pm the phone wasn't busy...only to be hung up on.... so I went to order there, but when I got there from just a couple blocks away I got the door locked in my face and told theywere close Read more
If I am going to be put on hold when ordering, I would like the person on the phone to have the courtesy to tell me I am being... put on hold--instead of putting down the receiver and ignoring me after I start my order. happened 7:20 p.m. 3/30/14 Read more
It's been a while. Haven't been since the Brighton location closed. Enjoyed going back. Love the bread sticks.