Reviews for Carle Place Diner in Carle Place, NY
Ist time here. Very good food and good service. Nice large portions of food.
Overall, the food was okay. The kids food was good, but my main dish (meatloaf), was dried out and smothered in gravy to cover... it up. It wasn't terrible, but would not suggest it. Service was outstanding and they were very accommodating and helpful, I wasalone with 3 of my 5 children. Read more
Food was average at best, the gravy and iced tea had almost no taste. I had asked if they had fresh brewed iced tea and I was... told yes, when I received it it was obviously from The fountain and not fresh brewed. The only positive thing about theestablishment was that the table and waiter service was very attentive and very good but food-wise there is no reason to go back Read more
Very good customer service. I felt welcomed. My food was good: bison burger was not dry and neither were the fries. The side... greek salad was fresh as well. Read more
The Carle Place Diner is a bit of a throwback to the diners of 30 years ago. Family run, better than mediocre food but the staff... was patient, friendly and responsive. I usually don't expect much from diners because of their nature; the menus are alwaystoo big, the place has too many customers. Carle Place Diner survives even post pandemic still even a bit better than before, and good for them. Their fried chicken is freshly made and not frozen. I do believe they need to work on their fries a bit asthey get too soggy too fast (double-fry will fix that). Their burgers are big and plentiful. They serve the classic slaw andpickles and their silver dollar pancakes are a bit more than a silver dollar. I decided to try their Cheesesteak egg roll justto see if it was worth the ten bucks and honestly it's pretty impressive! Read more
The poached eggs were almost completely done. This is okay cause the service was fantastic. Very diner need to season food to... your taste. Read more
A diner where has a jukebox on a table?! I fell in love with this cute retro vibe joint - fast service, friendly staffs and... delicious food. Add extra cheese on your omelette, you will like it even more! Read more
The food was delicious I got the balsamic grilled chicken panini and from texture to flavor it was on point! The food took a... while to come out after placing an order that's why I gave 4/5 for service but the host and server were very nice and attentive! Read more