Reviews for Keeler’s Neighborhood Steakhouse in Carefree, AZ
Visited Keeler's last week for the first time with a friend and I was very impressed. We had heard about this place from my... friends parents and we were glad we decided to go! The service was amazing. Our waitress was super knowledgeable about the menuand very attentive. Our appetizer, drinks, steaks and dessert were fantastic. I will say I got the Mac and cheese and the frenchonion soup as sides and they definitely lacked luster compared to the rest of the meal. They were just very plain and not what Iexpected compared to everything else. I loved that the owner visited our table! Made it feel very personal meeting the owner.Thank you for a wonderful dining experience. Will definitely be back when I'm back in the area. Read more
This is the place you go when the fancy resort food just isn't cutting it. Everything we ate there was delicious. They even have... gluten free options. Their Creme Brulee was the best I've ever had. Ate the whole thing even though I was already really full. Read more
My Husband Scott called to see if they had reservations as we don’t live in the area and we’re riding a motorcycle. He spoke... to Sunny and right from the start she was great. We arrived and spoke with her who had a table for us inside and couldn’t havebeen more accommodating. We were seated and our wonderful server John was amazing in so many ways. We live in NY and enjoyeating out. We can honestly say this food was one of the best places we have ever ate at. The filet, crab cakes, scallopedpotatoes and Brussel sprouts were amazing. Can’t wait to come out and will definitely be visiting them again. To top off thenight with their cheesecake and fresh coffee!! Thank you to John, Sunny, and Taylor for going above and beyond to make our lastnight in town and dinner so memorable. Beautiful restaurant inside and out. Highly recommend stopping there. Beautiful setting!! Read more
Visited with a group of work colleagues and had a great meal on their outdoor patio. The patio is equipped with misters which... kept us all quite comfortable. The food and service were top notch. I had the filet with grilled asparagus and mashed potatoes.Cooked to perfection! Read more
Mac and cheese was okay, could’ve used some parmigiana to top off. Brussels sprouts were undercooked, and the medium rare... steak ???? came out medium. But the wine ???? was good at happy hour. Brisket burger ???? came out cold, but otherwise goodokay. Read more
I would say it’s one of my favorite restaurants in the Carefree/Cave Creek area. It’s a really consistent, casual, American... Contemporary cuisine with tons of indoor, outdoor, and even rooftop seating (a really nice option in the Spring or late Fall).Tonight we chose to sit outdoors and being December 26th it was very cold outside but the heaters felt nice and made it quitewarm. Our server was very polite and attentive and management checked in on us mid meal as well. Parking is plentiful and theyalso have a large bar right behind the hostess stand. I started the meal with the French Onion Soup and it was actually reallytasty. Prepared classic style with a deep brown broth (my preference instead of the white colored style) and plenty of Gruyèremelted on top. For my entree I chose the 12oz Filet Mignon which had a nice char to it as well as a nice taste. I woulddefinitely order it again I finished every bite. Finally for dessert I topped off the meal with a few scoops of strawberry andcaramel gelato. An all around great meal! I would suggest to anyone for almost any occasion. It is a casual setting so may notbe right for certain formal meals but for a nice dinner it would be a great choice any night. Read more
We are so lucky to have a great place like Keeler’s in the neighborhood. The staff is incredible and very attentive. All have... excellent recommendations. Tana and Will at the bar really make the place special. We like that we can go and have a greatburger and beers, or enjoy steaks with wine, or even have cocktails. Read more
What a great find. Fantastic food, great service, fabulous cocktails and the outdoor patio was great with the heaters .. We... hadn't been here before but will definitely be back. The stakes and lamb are done to perfection. Read more