Reviews for Pirates Cove Pizza & Subs in Cardington, OH
Ordered a sub, salad and toco wedges. Sub ways soggy, toco wedges were not fully cooked, salad was just shredded lettce and... canned tomatoes and a little bit of cheddar cheese on it. Not at all what I expected, it was all plan tasting, verydisappointed! Read more
I wanted no tomato and you put tomato so one star
You will not be disappointed with their subs. Best you are going to find in the area.
First time trying, and wasn't disappointed. Food was hot and fresh. Employees were inviting while very busy.
Hands down the best pizza around. They use fresh product, and you can definitely tell in the taste. If you haven't tried them... out, do it. You won't be disappointed! Read more
This was our first time eating there ( we are not from there) everyone was friendly food was great!
The pizza dough was so dry, sauce was way too sweet. They cut it too soon to the cheese was everywhere and every time you took a... bite it was only sauce. Worst pizza I've ever gotten from here! Read more
My favorite place for subs they give you your money's worth