Reviews for Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls in Cape May, NJ

Lobster roll was very good .. we got one "Jumbo" and it was definitely more meat . No seating inside but they had covered gables... outside... service was good .. pretty quick.. only downer was the Lobster bisque. Which was weirdly sour and just mediocre atbest Read more

Lobster rolls overall were good, but I would have preferred the lobster roll to be warm. Also, having a better selection of... drinks would have been nice. Only bottled water was available. Read more

I am glad I got my first lobster roll from this place. Even my 6 year old got one and finished faster that I did mine. It was... the right size and ratio (bread/meat). The service is average and there are barely any seats or tables to eat on the spotbecause the 2 times we went the place was packed ( mostly families with little kids eating chicken fingers and fries :| ) Ican't comment on the prices since I haven't tried any other places, but I can say with confidence that this place has set thebar high. Read more

Went here by Google reviews craving for some good lobster meat ! First thing first , the prices are good for comparable rolls... but the quantity of meat is less. Though the menu says a Cape Cod kettle chip but we were served a classic lays chip. I likethe bun served toasted and warm to go with the cold lobster meat , but the bun was cold as well. Didn?t had a good experienceand maybe will try their beach outlet next time. Read more

My lobster Roll was all that and a bag of chips! Literally! ???? I was so hungry I forgot to take a picture so I went back a... second day and took it to the beach. Here?s a picture of me happy on the beach with my Lobster Roll! Great price for good food!Friendly ppl working there too! ???????? Read more

Husband and I discovered this place on our recent trip to Cape May and fell in love! These lobster rolls are amazing!!! We ate... lunch here every day. So sad we'll have to wait until our next Cape May trip to enjoy again. Read more

Wonderful lobster rolls! The best I?ve ever had. We went back for seconds! The rolls have massive chunks of lobster, on a... slightly toasted, buttery bun. It resets expectations for what a lobster roll could be. Read more

A generous serving of lobster with each roll. You know the food is fresh cause you see them making it in the kitchen. The person... that took my order was very nice and told me that they were the size of hot dog buns. I was a little disappointed to hear thesize but when I saw what they made, I changed my mind. They jam packed the bun with lobster! It tasted really good too! We wentduring happy hour and got them for $11 each. Not a bad price considering the amount of lobster on it. Read more