Reviews for The Horse & Sulky Pub & Grill in Campbell Hall, NY

Food was less than stellar. Steak was over cooked. Ordered medium can't out well done. Potatoes soup was gritty, mashed potatoes... were warm not hot and we're lumpy and uneven in consistency. Read more

Can't say enough about the food was fabulous the service was fabulous the people in the barn were fabulous I will definitely be... back thank you so much. Read more

Stopped for lunch. The steak sandwich with hot dip was great. I like the pub atmosphere and the people are nice.

Nice place the bartender and waitress are super nice and friendly. Food was good and reasonably priced. Karaoke night so that... added to the fun. Only bad thing that later in the evening while enjoying karaoke I witness a roach crawling across the bartop.grossed me out a bit. I'll definatenitely go again fir thr atmosphere and karaoke but I might just pass on the food....thebartender (Allise I believe) has an amazing voice.def. worth listening to. Read more

Great food& drinks with friendly service and a clean & cozy atmosphere. I took my mother for Christmas Eve dinner after plans... changed and was pleasantly surprised by how great the food was. The portion sizes were great. We had enough to take homeleftovers for lunch the next day. And the vegetables were fresh, not frozen. From the food to our friendly server, everythingmade us feel at home. We will be back soon. Read more

This place is pretty great. The food was delicious as were the drinks... The environment is aesthetically pleasing... Very... rustic. Wide selection of drinks and food. The service is a little bit slow, however, there was one person serving both the barand the restaurant, so lack of time efficiency is understandable. Overall it was a great experience and I will most likelyreturn. Read more

Surprisingly high quality food for a bar! They were very nice and so personable. The veggies were super fresh! Will be going to... more frequently. Read more

Good neighborhood go to place. Not fancy, down to earth with cozy atmosphere with always friendly staff. Fresh juicy burgers and... big salad portions. Tasty options. If there would be a neg thing to say than that the dining area is a bit cramped. But thesmall size is also what makes it cozy. Read more