Reviews for Angeloni's Restaurant and Pizzeria in Caldwell, NJ

Pizza is incredibly thing and incredibly delicious. Price is a little steep for a pie that can maybe feed one person due to the... thinness, but you definitely are getting what you pay for. Good quality pizza. Also complimentary garlic knots and bread.Establishment is very clean and nice inside. Read more

The tinny thin for the winny win. One of the most unique and crispy pies I have ever had. It is a must try!

This is one of our favorite restaurants and our kids constantly beg to go back here. Their pizza is definitely our favorite in... the area. A lot of people talk about how good Star Tavern is, but if you like that style of pizza, the Thinny Thin blows itaway. Other favorites are the long hots with sausage and potatoes and the Cesar salad. It’s a family run business and thestaff are always friendly and the service is great. Its BYOB, so don’t forget to grab singing on the way. Read more

The Food here is excellent! Clams oreganata- not overly cooked with good lemon sauce Carbonara- on point, one of the... best Calamari- well fried Garlic knots are excellent, very garlicy and buttery Chicken masala on a bed of spinach isoutstanding! Will repeat! Read more

I wish I could give it 0 stars! This used to be one of our favorite take out places until last few orders. First it was chicken... fingers that were soaked in oil, cold, and barely cooked. I called talked to the manager and they credited the amount towardsnext order. Thought it can happen to any of us until now. I ordered a broccoli and cheese calzone which was served withROTTEN, ORANGE broccoli (see photos). When I opened the box the smell really hit me I lifted the dough from the top to find whatyou can see in the photo. Absolutely disgusting! I though I was going to vomit. I called the the “on duty manager”said sorryyou want me to send replacement? Like it’s not a big deal. I’m sorry this place will kill someone serving old rotten food. Iasked for them to pick it up so she can see and understand how serious this was, only for me to have to call back an hour laterbecause no one was coming. I told the person who answered that she really needs to report it to the owners. She took my name andnumber. Still no call from the owner! They clearly do not take their customers seriously or care that their chef and qualitycontrol served spoiled food. Be ware eat at your own risk! Read more

Angeloni's opened to great fanfare because the food was good, but also because Caldwell pizza lovers thought it a great... alternative to Star closer to home. It has made its own mark by now, with its thin pizza and its even thinner "thinny thin" piesthe stuff of legend (or hate, it's that way!). The regular menu items are good too. Definitely a great place to have acomforting meal. Read more

Very very good. Got everything half garlic The grandma's stood out the best to me And the appetizer meatballs with garlic. But i... switched the cheese to fresh mozzarella But well worth the trip and stop Go and try for yourself Good jobguys ???????????????????????????? Read more

Amazing pizza great service. Pizza was so good even my 3 year old had 2 full slices and she's not a big eater. We'll def be back... again Read more