Reviews for Mustachio's Pizzeria in Buffalo, NY
I go here often and Mustachio's never disappoints. Their pizza is probably my favorite - best pepperoni in town! And don't sleep... on the medium wing sauce, delish. Read more
Fast, friendly, and attentive. I've never had a bad order from this business. The food is delicious, but the customer service is... PEAK. They really seem to care about their customers and take extra care where needed to make sure each order is handled withcare. 10/10 100% of the time. Keep up the amazing work. Read more
Absolutely delicious! We just ordered pizza and wings for my daughters party yesterday and everyone LOVED the food. We had the... chicken finger pizza, cheese and pep and cheese pep and hot peppers. All perfectly made! We also had 4 flavors of wings (garlicparm , bbq on the pit , hot and med) and the were all DELICIOUS! we come to mustachios all the way from Grand Island and itnever disappoints! Great pizza , great wings and great staff! Read more
Ordered Sicilian, extra black Olives. Loved it. It was fresh and the size for the price was very good. Definitely going back.
I?ve come in for slices regularly since I found this lovely pizza joint, never ordered a whole pizza. I told my friend about... this place and he wanted to try it out so we ordered a large pizza and it?s absolutely delicious. Definitely my favorite pizzaspot in Buffalo. Read more
A lot of people have seen my last review about mustachios regarding a bad experience that I had with the pizza back a month ago.... After the owner was aware of it he Immediately took action to solve the problem and for that I am grateful. I will leave somepictures here of the pizza we received today for my son?s birthday. It was really good and cooked to perfection. Read more
This place seems to keep getting better. Classic buffalo style pizza. Dough was thick and fluffy and had a buttery crust.... Everything I have had here is good. Definitely recommend giving this sleeper a try Read more
I ordered a large pizza and 20 wings and the food was absolutely disgusting!! The pizza was under cooked and a sloppy mess.... However the biggest issue was their wings!! They smelled like they were rotten! They were so disgusting that no one would eveneat them. Obviously this place cares nothing for customer service. A senile old man took my order and it took him 4 ttys and 30minutes to ring up a large pizza and 20 wings, the pizza was an under cooked sloppy mess and the chicken wings smelled andtasted rotten. If you order from this pizzeria you better hope they aren't busy because if so they obviously could care lessabout the quality of the food they give you!... I paid over 50 for the pizza and wings and it was so gross we ended up throwingit out!!! DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PIZZERIA....THEYRE SOOOOO MANY BETTER CHOICES!!!! Read more