Reviews for St. Anselm in Brooklyn, NY
INCREDIBLE. Indoors is very warm and cozy. Outdoors is like a backyard family reunion. Comfort food. Everything we had was... fantastic. Note: they serve beer and wine, no liquor. For 2 we had: grilled artichoke hearts, wine braised octopus, butcherssteak, NY strip steak, and long beans. Both steaks medium rare. Everything was delicious and cooked perfectly, but the #1 mustorder is the Butcher’s steak. Read more
We came here as a recommendation for a friend and it did not disappoint. The steak was delicious and the price was for what you... get is really great. We also got the chicken and it was perfectly cooked. The chefs here really know what they are doing and ifwant to have really good steak and chicken without the frills or a steakhouse I highly recommended coming here. Perfect for adate night or girls/boys night. Read more
I went here with a group and was excited for this dinner! Every dish we had was good! I was afraid I won't get full but when we... had the Mears, especially the Tomahawk, everyone in the table were quiet! We enjoyed every bite! As with the tomahawk, we triedto get as much meat as possible because it was that good! I'd go back here again! Read more
We ordered the burrata, pan fried mash potatoes and hanger steak. All the dishes were delicious and well balanced, the stakeout... was the ganger steak with pan fried mash potatoes. I love the crispy outside and the soft and fluffy potatoes in the inside.Perfect way to add texture and a genius dish. Read more
St. Anselm never disappoints! You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Plus, the staff are all so kind, attentive, and... knowledgeable. They're usually pretty busy, so even with a reservation, you may still end up needing to wait a little bit(totally worth it). They'll suggest you go to the bar next door to grab a drink (cute little bar with backyard area and greatselection of beer and wine), and they'll come grab you when your table is ready. You can bring the drinks over to therestaurant, so you don't need to rush to finish your drink or anything. Honestly, it's all part of the experience. The food isamazing, drinks are great, and the dessert selection is excellent. Read more
Came here to celebrate my birthday yesterday. LOVE the butcher’s steak! We had medium rare, and it’s PERFECT! So tender, the... seasoning is awesome. Bacon, spinach, and smashed potatoes are tasty! Must try their Toffee Cake with vanilla ice cream. Myfirst time having a toffee cake that’s not that sweet. (It’s a big compliment from Asian, IYKYK????) However, I won’t givefive stars to the octopus. The taste was great, but the octopus was dry. Overall experience definitely worth five stars. Read more
Wanted to try a different steak house outside of Manhattan, we were referred to St Anselm by a friend and it did not disappoint!... The atmosphere was a mixture of cozy rhythm and blues music in a local casual dining setting. We sat at the “chef table”,were we enjoyed views of the progressive all women chefs cooking up some beautiful steaks. They were quiet and calmlycommunicating orders which came out at reasonable time and all at once! Everything about this placed flowed so perfectly even asa blizzard was storming outside. I had the Butchers steak, NY strip steak and the chicken. But I got to say the Pan Fried mashpotatoes was AMAZING!! I would easily come back just for that and a glass of wine. The steaks were cooked perfectly and the wineselection is great. Make no mistake I will be back for more! Great for a cozy night on the town or a wine date especially ifyour used to the easily packed steak houses of the city! Read more
Love this place!!! All the more because they cover their steaks in BUTTER. Great starters and drinks + vibes. Tomahawk steak was... way too ambitious for a party of two but we settled on the boneless black angus ribeye and it did not disappoint. The absolutestar of the show. Scallops were pretty solid too. Yes i posted two pictures of the same steak. Sue me. This place is great.Ended the night with a sticky toffee pudding. Gut buster but great splurge meal once in a while. Read more