Loading

Reviews for Milly's Pizzeria in Brooklyn, NY

Jacob Trubey 1 year ago
5

Best pizza I had in New York

Aaron Lee 1 year ago
5

Though small, it has a friendly atmosphere and the food is always a banger. Best Pizza spot in Bedstuy.

Carlos Leon 1 year ago
4

Pizza was good but it could have used more sauce on it.

Alana Rodriguez 2 years ago
5

Me and my kids love the pizza here. Friendly staff.

Ozkar Winter 2 years ago
3

Very friendly and welcoming but unfortunately the pizza wasn’t as good as I was hoping it would be. Based on the reviews, I... was hoping for pretty good pizza but didn’t enjoy it and didn’t have much flavor. Read more

Blackmist 2 years ago
5

Although expensive, this place genuinely has the best pasta around. Their sauce is freshly made and tastes like it too. Delivery... is fast and their people are patient and friendly. You cannot go wrong ordering anything here because you know it'll be madewith love. Read more

Rachel Hill 3 years ago
5

best spot in the neighborhood for quick italian eats! always fresh & delicious, good portions, & good prices. the staff are so... sweet and friendly every time. if you like pasta, i very much recommend their eggplant parm!!! it is consistently fantastic. ikeep forgetting to take pics before i'm already halfway through. one of these days... Read more

Soghomon 3 years ago
5

“Where a Costumer Comes In And a Friend Goes Out” captures the essence Milly’s Pizzeria. Not only the best pizza, the... greatest salads, the most magnificent calzones, and the best wings this side of the pizza oven, but Milly’s also has thefriendliest, most attentive staff of any pizzeria in all of Brooklyn. A big and generous thank you goes out to the great peoplethat makes Milly’s possible- a true pleasure every time!!! ???? Did I mention open late? Yes, they are ???? Read more