Loading

Reviews for Mayfield in Brooklyn, NY

Lourdes Zephier 2 years ago
5

Excellent food and service. Very talented chef with impeccable attention to detail. The presentations are delicate, thoughtful,... exciting, enticing, and so much more. Engaging staff and service. This restaurant has a welcoming vibe. Read more

Dawson Blackhouse 2 years ago
4

Great service. The smoked reuben and fries were good. Especially for a to-go order. But the onion to lettuce ratio in the salad... was 1:1. Probably more onions than lettuce. See photo Read more

Megan McCourt 2 years ago
5

What a gem! Mayfield is the perfect date spot--dark and cozy, slightly upscale but still comfy, easy to get a table, tasty and... affordable food and drinks. Started with martinis, oysters and a kale salad (divine!), and shared a fried chicken sandwich andpatty melt. Both the sandwiches were enormous (we could've shared just one), incredible, and came with delicious fries andsalad. Rounded out the night with some of the olive oil cake, don't miss out on this for dessert!! Impeccable service, perfectvibes, and the check for all that food was under $90 (unheard of!) with leftovers to spare. My new favorite date spot!! Read more

Fred 2 years ago
5

Spareribs with fried pickles were really tender and tasty. Oyster po boy could have used a little more bite, but was pretty... solid. Beer selection put together thoughtfully. Both desserts we tried were excellent: olive oil cake with compote was light onsugar which allowed the fruit and citrus to take front and center; the donuts were cooked perfectly and were very rich, as youwould expect by the description. Service was very good. Attentive and thoughtful but not pushy. Read more

Parker Feierbach 2 years ago
2

it's... Fine. I've been going here for years. The service is and never has been great. I used to come for the fries (great... fries) and oysters but it looks like they changed the fry recipe (they went from breaded twice-fried to what looks like boxedOre Ida fries, a huge downgrade). Probably won't be coming back any time soon, unfortunately. Bring back the old fries! Read more

Amanda Bernardine 2 years ago
5

One of my favorite neighborhood spots...lovely staff and great food especially the steak tar tar

A Booth 2 years ago
5

One of my favorite chicken sandwich, and the burger is pretty good too. Both come with a massive amount of fries that are... cooked to perfection Read more

Omotola Mujota 2 years ago
2

The oysters and drinks are good here. Service and entrees are meh at best; save the fish and chips. They also aren’t very... honest in terms of billing. They charged me for an extra drink, I noticed and complained. They supposedly fixed it but my totalwas the same. And they altered my tip after I left. Yikes. Read more