Reviews for Best Pizza in Brooklyn, NY
I got the cheese and the Sicilian, which were both joyous! I?ve always loved eating spoonfuls of marinara sauce out of the jar,... which was just about the experience of eating the Sicilian?just with even better marinara! The crust was soft and spongy, with abit of tang. The classic cheese was the best NYC-style slice I?ve had. Not like basil is a surprise on pizza, but the basil andthe homemade mozzarella made for an unexpected flavor burst! Read more
Great pizzas with a nice and thin dough. I really liked the white slice. Pepperoni and grandma were decent as well. Finished 2... slices with ease (excluding the crust). The restaurant was lacking cleanliness though, even spotted a cockroach crawling on thewall. Read more
I loved the Sicilian and Grandma Slice. So so good. Very high quality ingredients and the dough was super light, airy and crisp.... The NY slice was also fire but I do prefer the little cupped pepperonis more. They make their own mozzarella and you can tell.Prices are cheap, service is friendly and the place looks cool. Overall definitely a great puritan NY Pizza stop. Read more
Really like the margarita slice very much, as the cheese and tomato ratio well very even and well spread out. Coming out hot... from the oven, the cheese really does melts in your mouth. The crust is also thin, chewy and slightly salty. Tried the Grandmaslice as well and a bit heavy for my taste and I guess just not used to it. Service was good, and the guy taking the order andcollecting payment was really nice and friendly. Read more
The atmosphere inside feels like old school Brooklyn. I've tried 3 slices ( cheese, pepperoni, and grandma) they all were really... good. The dough of the pizza has a great texture and quality. You can also tell that they use fresh ingredients. Pair it with abeer and you are good to go. Read more
My bf said this was the best pizza he?s ever had in his life! The crust is delicious and thin and just perfect. If you?re in the... area I highly recommend. I think the white slice is the best. Read more
Born and raised in New York , pizza is the most important thing when it comes to staple foods . Living my whole life in... Brooklyn is always a debate who has the best pizza , many recommend this place so wanted to see for myself what?s the bighype. When I walked in it look like a typical Pizza joint, I got the opportunity to speak to Brian and he gave us a small tourand explanation of this establishment. How the oven is over 120 years old , how they use Oak to make the fire and they preparemozzarella in-house and how many hours it takes for the onions to cook (I believe he said six , I could be wrong) Also got theopportunity to meet the owner super friendly down to earth humble man. The vibe is amazing feels very Brooklyn. Customerservice five stars I had the opportunity to order regular Pizza pie ,grandma and the white pizza everything was amazing . Thincrust very delicious . Hands-down top 5 Pizza places I have ever tried. Also had a arugula salad very good. I highly recommendto visit this spot . Just sit enjoy every bite. Read more
Definitely in the top 3 pizzas in NYC. Their grandma slice is the best I?ve had so far. Crunchy and fluffy and saucy. Can?t beat... it. The white slice is also worth trying. Amazing flavour. Read more