Reviews for Gaetano's Steaks in Brooklawn, NJ
I placed an order for cheese steak , medium pizza and a buffalo chicken salad. We I arrived I had fries instead of a pizza and... my salad look like slop. I will never order from there again Read more
First and last time eating at this specific location! Ordered a 17? cheese steak might as well been a 12? the amount of meat... they put on it. I had to drive back up there to get another order of French fries after they left my first order in the greasetoo long basically potato chips. Read more
My first time there. They are INCREDIBLE! Had a Boston Chicken Cheese Steak and it was the best steak I have ever had-and I've... had a lot of cheese steaks in my day. The onion rings were fantastic as well. They are 40 minutes from my house-and I'll gladlybe making that trip often from now on! A+++ Read more
1st time good sandwich nothing special got a large ch steak sub
Gaetano's still has large fulfilling, great tasting sandwiches. They also remodeled the place & it looks great. I will return!
I ordered a large pizza with mushrooms,black olives, and pepperoni, and barbecue wings. The food was great, the pizza crust and... size of the slices was impeccable. The cheese was long thick and stringy ..... The wings were big juicy and very tasty. I willdefinitely return Read more
I thought I was going to love this place when I sat down. The fact that they actually had a salt shaker full of garlic on the... table made me think that this place was going to be awesome. I got the garlic bread cheese steak with peppers, and the textureof the meat was more like hamburgers than steak. The entire bottom of my sandwich was completely soggy. I almost sent it back,wich I have only done a couple times in my life. Im from Detroit, but I have came to expect great things from cheese steaks inthis area. I was disappointed. One guy ordered a side of sausage and said it didn't even taste like sausage. The gravy friessounded awesome, but were just fries, with a couple slices of provolone, covered in some tasteless, runny, brown gravy. Thechicken cheese steak by buddy ordered looked great. Another guy in our party ordered two cheese slices and they were huge andlooked great. Maybe it was just what I ordered, but I just wasn't impressed. Clean place, friendly staff, several flat screensif you want to watch a game. Read more
I love their pizza and curly fries with cheese! If you dine in the pizza slices are huge, Take out they are regular size. I?ve... never left still hungry and I?ve Always enjoyed my meal. Their cheesesteaks are also great, huge size with nice helping of meat. Read more