Reviews for Varney's Restaurant in Brookhaven, NY
Food was very good. However you need to fight the flies for your meal if you eat inside. Service very slow. Could be cleaner.... Other than that food is delicious. So if you don?t mind swatting away the flies or being bit by the flies give it a try. Read more
Food was fresh and delicious, staff was friendly.
Excellent little restaurant, good friendly service and good atmosphere. The steamed muscles with white sauce was excellent and... the butter lobster rolls where so good, you just want more. Even the fries and coleslaw where top notch. Will definitely go backto try other choices Read more
I ordered dinner for my wife and I. We both had cold lobster rolls that came with thick crispy fries, coleslaw and a pickle. The... lobster rolls were delicious and plentiful and the coleslaw was sweet not vinegary. This can be improved by using crushedpineapple with the juice and not use the raw sugar. It makes a summer slaw that?s to good to pass on. We also split a dozenbaked clams. The baked clams tasted like smoked paprika. That?s it. No taste of clams or parsley at all. Not good. The place isclean and service was fast and friendly. $$$$ out of $$$$$ Read more
It was cozy and the staff was friendly. Seems like a local spot. The food was decent. Basic stuff. Burger and fries were good.... Fish sandwich was good. No wow factor. The place can use a makeover. It's old and a bit rundown. It seems to want to be aseafood/coastal restaurant but it just misses the mark. A few tweaks on the menu and on the esthetic and this can be a hoppinplace. Read more
The food is delicious and it is always a good experience eating here! The baked clams are one of the best I have tried and the... hot lobster roll is delicious!! Sometimes it can be too buttery so just tell them not too much butter and all is amazing! Greatprice and service! Read more
Best lobster roll I?ve ever had, I?ll probably have dreams about it. Don?t come expecting any frills inside but when you try... this lobster roll that will be the last thing on your mind. The fries left something to be desired but let?s face it, that?s notwhat you?re here for. Can?t wait to come back and try the cold lobster roll next time! Read more
Ordered take-out here and while the service was slow, the amazing Lobster Roll helped make up for it. You can tell that the... staff really care about the people and the business! Read more