Reviews for The Red Mill Inn & Pizza in Brookfield, WI
First time trying this restaurant. Great service! They currently are only open 3 days a week currently. They were out of their... popular appetizers. Will try to go earlier in the future. Crust was perfect thinness! Read more
Short staffed and limited menu now, but drinks and pizza are still fire. Specialty themed night- tequila. Phenomenal! food and... drinks are absolutely superb! Owners and staff are friendly and attentive. Highly recommend. Soft opening day 1- fantastic!Service was wonderful, staff extremely nice, and the food was wonderful!!! Cocktails, spinach artichoke dip, beer battered fishfry, potato pancakes, kids Italian chicken strips and fries...and the the gelato! ???? Absolutely wonderful Read more
The food was fresh and delicious! Our family ordered a small pizza(for the kids to share), a pizza burger, a roast beef dip... sandwich, and cocktails. The prices were fair and our bellies were happy. Read more
Red Mill is walking distance from my house I wish I could give a better review but unfortunately I can't I'm not going to say... the pizza is bad, but anyone who thinks this is good pizza has never had a good pizza. I also had the walleye fish fry verydisappointing small pieces smelled and tasted fishie Read more
Nice atmosphere and tasty food. We sat away from the bar area, as that part of the restaurant can be quite noisy. Liked watching... part of the basketball game on one of their large TVs. Cheese curds and garlic bread were pretty good. I really enjoyed theirthin crust sausage pizza too. Crust was a little too crispy and bubbled for me, but others in my party who enjoy thin crust morewere quite pleased. The sausage itself was very very good. Restaurant is located in a quiet residential area and we saw manypeople stop in for take-out. Seems like a nice place! Read more
What a wonderful variety of pizza. We had the Italian beef version, very tasty, albeit a little salty. Drank a lot of beer... afterwards, and that's not a bad thing! Read more
I ordered one Margherita Pizza, triple meat ball appetizer, and a build your own pizza. Attached is a photo of the undercooked... meatball. The pizza crust was soggy, and the Margherita was stone cold. Just an imbarrasement. I will not be going back there,and you should think twice about going there. Read more
Tried yesterday for first time for a pizza. Ordered specifically with no black olives. Got pizza home and took out of bag and it... was covered with black olives ! My receipt said no black olives. Simple mess up by kitchen but ruined my families taste fortheir pizza. To bad...many great pizza places in area. Will not be back....loved it when it was butches Read more