Reviews for Grateful Head Pizza Oven & Tap Room in Broken Bow, OK

You know the pizza is gonna be good when there's the old red & white checkered plastic table cloths we grew up with on top of... the table.. uhm patio table. Pizza is amazing. The crust is ???? The wings are phenomenal & the salad is just as such. Servicewas great, we went on a Sunday night. That's your best bet of getting in the actual parking lot. On Friday & Saturdays, saveyour sanity & wait to dine in on a Sunday evening. Read more

Pretty cool place and the pizza was good. We got there dinner time and the wait was 15-20 minutes, not to bad. Our group of five... shared two large pizzas and it was more than enough, even had Togo pizza. We ordered the case Jones and supremo pizza. Both weregreat. The side salads looked good as well. I didn?t have one. I will say beer is pricey, $6 for a domestic is concert prices. Ididn?t check if that was okey 3.2 beer. Read more

We got there early in the day which i would suggest if you're going for lunch to beat the crowd. We were seated right away but... there was a wait shortly thereafter. The service was very good. We had an order of hot wings (plenty of heat) and the cosmicCharlie pizza between 4 people. Both were very good. If there was anything to complain about it would only be how long the pizzatook to come out after we ordered it but the server kept us updated and it was totally fine. Read more

Food was really good but they were out of so much stuff like pepperoni! What pizza place runs out of pepperoni?? Also the beer... and soda was not available. Cheese sticks were good. The cosmic Charlie pizza was phenomenal especially with their house maderanch. Still irritated by the pepperoni but was good over all. Read more

My wife and I went because only they had gluten free pizza here. My wife got the gluten free pizza with no cheese and I told... them to be very careful about how they made hers. As for me, I got a normal pizza. The atmosphere was not that great in myeyes and the bathroom needs updating as you will see the pictures. Our waitress was really cool and patient with me as my wifewas using ASL to speak and I interpreted it. She also was very prompt in refilling my root beer. We found out that this placehas gluten free beer. Of course I got that and it was good. It had a pineapple taste which was nice. I asked if it was localand she went to ask her boss and sadly it was not and came from California. Now for the pizza. Well for the pizza I got itcost 28 dollars for a large and my wife's gluten free pizza cost 17 dollars for a small. There is no medium and that is what itcost for all of them. The pizza I had looked flat and not awesome for 28 dollars. The taste was decent but not wow. As for mywife's gluten free pizza, she said the crust was burnt on the edges which means they cooked it too long. I am 100% sure that itwas not a house made crust and I am 100% sure the pizza sauce was not made fresh because our waitress told us that it came froma can. All in all I feel that it's a one visit for me. Meaning we tried it and now we do not have to go there again. Oh ourbill came up to 61 dollars and that's without tip for two people. Read more

This pizza is legit. I tried their hot wings, cheesy Styx and The Dire Wolf Pizza. All were great. I thought the cheesy sticks... would be mozzarella sticks. Instead it was basically a small cheese pizza without sauce cut in thin slices. However, it wasreally good. The Pizza was very filling. I shared a large with my two kids and husband and we some left over. The toppings arereal deal and hardy. I truly enjoyed the food. The restaurant is quirky in a good way. The staff was extremely friendly. We didhave sticker shock though. The drinks were $8 and the pizza was $28. The appetizers were reasonably priced. Read more

We are from Texas visiting and someone recommended to stop here. First off all the buildings and establishments have such a home... feel to them. People are friendly but this was probably the best pizza I?ve had in a while!! Service is great. I thought forsome reason the cheese sticks were mozzarella sticks but they are not deep fried and they did not disappoint on bit! Happy totake home extra pizza and cheese sticks. Great souvenir cups when you order a soda. Read more

Great atmosphere, amazing pizza! I ordered the Pig Pen, which is essentially a Pepperoni Lovers pizza. They definitely give you... your money's worth of Pepperoni. You can tell that they put a lot pride in their pizza. It was easy to see that ???? is theirstrongest strength. I also ordered cheese Styx. It was pretty much a cheese pizza without a marinara base. I asked for dippingsauce and they gave me tons of marinara and tons of their homemade ranch. I love the effort they put into pleasing thecustomers. Most places would have only given me one sauce of each. Then I ordered hot wings. They use their own dry rub recipeand then bake them till they have the perfect char. All the food was delicious and I would definitely recommend that you givethem a try. Especially the pizza! Best in OK. That was the standout for me. Read more