Reviews for Mystic Lobster Roll Co Brick in Brick Township, NJ

Delicious lobster rolls had the LBI roll and a classic Connecticut roll and was very impressed!! The coleslaw is delicious too!!... Very beautiful inside n immaculate! I?ve gotten to meet the owner when we came in n she was very friendly! Def recommend!! Read more

Mystic?s lobster rolls are amazing. The best thing is they have 10 different specialty lobster roll options. From The LBI to... their Philly lobster rolls you can?t go wrong with any of them. It wasn?t until my 15th trip that I finally tried their regularnon specialty roll. Give a try you won?t be disappointed!! Read more

It SUCKED!!! Very expensive $20.99 for a little Lobster Roll with a tiny container of coleslaw. Not worth the money. The lobster... roll was just OK. We should have known when we walked in the door & the place was empty!!! Check this place off my list. Read more

This place is hard to find because it's located in the corner of the strip mall, the lobster roll was excellent and the customer... service the woman who was at the register I didn't get her name and I do apologize she had such a great personality. If youdon't like what they have on the menu you can order anything and they'll make it the way you want it. I must try place worth the$22 and it comes with coleslaw and a pickle. Read more

Great lobsta rolls and other options for a treat. Lobster is not inexpensive but quality and quantity were very good. I ordered... mine Maine style which was always my favorite growing up on New England. Read more

Lobster roll was excellent and plenty of lobster. My only criticism was that the cole slaw portion was very small but it did... not detract from the lobster. I will eat there again. Read more

Quaint little gem in Brick. We had the Connecticut and New England lobster rolls comes with Cole slaw and pickle. Totally... delish! Lobster was fresh and cooked perfectly. Lobster Mac n cheese needed more Lobster for the price but was good too. Perfect spot to order some rolls and head to the beach. Read more

I went here for lunch with my Wife, my sister, and my brother in law. The Service and food were great. Lobster tasted fresh and... was cooked perfectly. We all enjoyed our food and all agreed this is a good lunch spot. The only issue I had was the pricepoint. Each roll was $22.00 plus Tax and the rolls are about a hot dog roll size. for 4 rolls 4 drinks and bag of chips sharedit was well over $100.00. I understand the price of lobster is market price, but for the amount of lobster on the roll, I had todo a double take. Like I said it's good for lunch and I would go back, just be wary of price Read more