Reviews for Zegarelli’s Restaurant Bar Pizza & Catering in Brewster, NY

I am not one to write bad reviews as I work in the industry myself, but the first time coming into this restaurant left a bad... taste in my mouth. I was delivering for doordash and came to pick up a take out order and had gone through the entrance door tothe bar, had been directed to the pick up desk and waited. I was greeted by a woman with short blonde hair who immediately said?Did you see that sign out there?. I was confused as it was my first time in the restaurant and she continued to point to thesign and rudely tell me that I was supposed to park around the other side and there was a sign telling me to do so and if I wasto come back to be sure to park and come in the correct door. I am not sure if she treats all customers that way or if it wasbecause I was a delivery driver but I definitely won?t be coming back as a driver or customer. Would give 0 stars if I could,customer service is the first step in any good restaurant and this lady had none. Read more

Owner was our waitress. Service was excellent. Food was sensational. Stuffed cabbage on the Oktoberfest menu best I have ever... had. Food perfectly cooked. Green beans freshly picked. Can't say enough good things.... Read more

Sat at the bar. Great bartender. Always nice and helpful. Food is good with familiar faces and music

The best food and service we have had yet living up here. Norma is the greatest. Wish we got to meet Angelo - maybe next time.

I simply love this cozy bar/restaurant, plenty of parking on the side and front of the restaurant, additional parking across... the street, food is definitely delicious. If you like your dish spicy like me, make sure you let them know. Read more

Great local restaurant to enjoy some quality food and drinks. Friendly attentive staff contribute to your enjoyment! Seems to be... a favorite hangout for the locals. Definitely a good spot to enjoy some food & drinks....and worth a try!! Read more

Great food, service and friendly staff. Crab cakes and calamari are good appetizers. Had linguini and clam sauce, chicken san... marine for main courses. Read more

Still a 5 star rating! My favorite dish is the spinach salad. Enormous enough to take some home and have for breakfast. Yes... breakfast yum!! Read more