Reviews for Pizza Place & Trattoria II in Brewster, NY
I have tried them twice, the first time I got a chicken wrap, it was so dry and tasteless( and I even asked for extra o&v) the... second time I ordered the chicken marsala hero, again asked for extra Marsala sauce, there was no sauce on it at all chunks ofdry white chicken, maybe 8 mushrooms, again absolutely no taste at all, maybe they are famous for the pizza, perhaps I'll trythat, maybe the third time is a charm...we shall see Read more
Spectacular pizza (buffalo chk slice in picture) and Greek salad. Smell is intoxicating walking in. Amazing service. I'm happy... we found this place! Read more
Traveled from the ADK and were going to be stuck in traffic..with two hungry kids we took a chance..it was AMAZING...
The name does have "pizza" in the title so I'm sure they're probably best at pizzas. We ordered a lasagna and chicken parm which... were awesome but the sides were a let down. Stay away from the garlic bread with cheese and the cheese fries. Read more
My family loves this spot! They are always accommodating, no cheese pizza? No problem. Wings with sauce on the side? Every... time! The food is fresh when delivered and once we got everything but our pizza and the manager delivered it in about 20minutes! Astounding service and always fresh, quality ingredients! Read more
THESE PEOPLE ARE AMAZING! I called to get a delivery to my best friend who just got engaged. I asked if they could do a heart... shape in pepperoni. Without hesitation they agreed- even though he said they have never done it before. It turned out GREAT! Andshe was so happy! THANK YOU! Read more
One of the best NY style pizza I?ve had at a reasonable price too. The slices were large with a good cheese to sauce ratio.... Sauce was a bit acidic, but not overwhelming. The dough was soft and held its form well, crust was crunchy on the outside andsoft within. It wasn?t oily either. Their garlic knots were a bit small, but you get 6. They were really soft and not toogarlicky. I?d get marinara sauce on the side. Read more
We absolutely love The Pizza Place! Fantastic food and friendly service! Thank you for making our Friday nights AWESOME family... pizza night!! Read more