Reviews for Nick-N-Willy's Pizza in Boulder, CO
Gross. Frozen pizza is better. It was undercooked, the peppers and onions on top were thick and crunchy. The cheese tasted... like processed cheese. The crust tasted like cardboard. It was the worst pizza I’ve ever had. We literally threw it away andwent and got dinner elsewhere. Read more
Great pizza. Very friendly. Great local business. Stop in when you get a chance.
I grew up going to Nick-n-Willys as a kid and now I have children of my own. I brought my five year olds to the restaurant and... the staff was incredibly nice, asking her questions, telling her about how they make their pizzas, flipping the dough in the airfor her, and even giving her a little piece of dough to play with herself! They went above and beyond to make sure we had agreat experience not to mention the pizza was just as good if not better than I remembered!! I’m so glad to see that thisrestaurant has remained one of the loveliest places with the best pizza in Boulder! Read more
I am a lil' tipsy right now, but the service is speedy and great. The tomatoes on my pizza were fresh and the dough was great.... If you want to come on down, then come on down ! Read more
When I placed the order, I didn't realize that it was a Take and Bake place. They were nice enough to bake it for me while I... waited. The pizza was good, but nothing out of the ordinary to justify the high price point. Worth a try if you want to checkouta new place. Probably won't be returning. Read more
Really great cheese pizza slice. I had the zesty garlic sauce instead of the red sauce. 4 stars only bc I prefer a more hand... tossed. This was thin crust but still good. Read more
I’ve had some great pizza in the US and all over the world... but there is a special character to Nick-N-Willy’s. Eating a... slice or a whole pie is about the experience this business provides. Starting with a great attitude from staff. Yes... agenuine good welcoming attitude. As a new transplant, this is my pizza place in Colorado! Love it! Read more
Nick N Willy's has always been my go to place when I didn't have time to cook--like today. No more. I ordered a Thai Pie. The... poultry had not been marinated and it looked and tasted like turkey, not chicken. One taste, and no one else would eat it.Everyone was surprised. When I called, he said that it was rotisserie chicken instead of their usual grilled chicken, buteveryone felt it was turkey. It was disgusting. Nick N Willy's has been around forever because of their consistently good food.They need to rethink what they are doing. Read more