Reviews for Olive Oils Pizzeria & More in Bethel Park, PA

I'm from California and I'm visiting my sister. She recommended this place so we got a hoagie. Omg! The Italian hoagie is the... best that I have ever had. Pizza was good too! I love this place. I will definitely be back before I go back to cali. Read more

Update to review below. Order did finally arrive, an hour after the quoted 45 minutes. The driver appeared to be a young kid,... nice and immediately apologized. I still don't understand why someone couldn't answer the phone or call to explain our foodwould be so late. We're pretty understanding but find it rude and annoying that no one could contact us or take our call. Inaddition, our medium BBQ chicken pizza that we order all the time was apparently made as a small or extra small for that matter. It's pathetic, like the size of a personal pan pizza from Pizza Hut. This experience has more than likely caused us to notorder anymore. Placed our order online at 4:58 pm. for delivery from the Bethel Park location. It's now 6:25 pm, still no foodand no one is answering the phone. States they're open untill 10pm tonight. Amount of our order has of course been taken outof our account. Such a shame because we really like their food. Not very good customer service. Read more

I stopped at olive oils tonight at 11:20? The sign on the door says they are open until midnight (still open) and the guy... working absolutely refused to prepare any food because he had already turn the oven off for the evening? I don?t see how this ismy problem. His exact words were ?that?s not my problem.? No class. Thanks for Nothing. Read more

My wife and I had some company over the other night, and we decided to get pizza. I've never tried Olive Oils, but someone... suggested it. I ordered online, and picked it up since it's close. We ordered 3 different pizzas, and an order of mozzarellasticks. When I entered they told me my order would be done soon. I didn't get his name, but he asked if we were having a partywith all the pizza. I explained that we had people over, and he ended up giving us a whole extra order for free that somebodyelse cancelled. The food was all fresh, and very good. You can tell they use premium ingredients, and know how to make awesomepizza. This will probably be our go to pizza place from now on. Thanks again! Read more

Today we ordered pizza and wings. The wing were so dry and overcooked they were not fit for eating. The pizza was supposed to... have sausage and olives on it. Could barely see any sausage. The worst food we have ever received from Olive Oils in Bethel. Iwon?t be ordering from them anytime soon. Read more

I ordered the flying pig. This has to be the dumbest sandwich I think I've ever ordered. It tasted great but it was the... equivalent of adding everything and seeing what works. It works, but my goodness it has too many ingredients. Their calzones arereally good too. I ordered the Italian calzone and it was really good. The staff is always polite and professional. The locationcan't be beat. I would recommend if you're really hungry and want a lot of food for a small amount of money. Read more

Ordered for the first time using the online order & delivery. I ordered at around 10:00am and got an email confirmation that... said about 45min depending on how busy they were. By 11:45am I did call to check in and offer to pick up if faster - theysounded very busy but the employee who answered the phone was friendly and assured me it would be here in a few minutes. Within5 minutes it was delivered by a friendly delivery person. Food was delicious and worth the wait. If you're prepared to wait awhile, its very good and they're very friendly! Read more

This place makes a great product for the price you pay, and it has been ready to pick up in 20 minutes or less each time. This... is among the most competitively priced pizza chains in the area -- it's a great baseline pizza with a nice aged cheese flavor.The staff have always been friendly and the product has always exceeded my expectations. Give this place a try! Read more