Reviews for Papa Angelo's Pizzaria in Bethany, OK

This is the best pizza. This is the best pizza! Garlic knots are also amazing! Great pizza friendly staff! You must give this... family owned business a try! Don't want to commit to a whole pizza? They sell it by the slice until 2:00 PM! Read more

Our first visit to Papa Angelo's was great. Excellent pizza and garlic knots. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. We had... an Empire size pizza (20") and with three adults it was a plenty of food. My wife really enjoyed the chocolate cake as well. Read more

My favorite Pizza in OKC (located in Bethany)! We dropped by and ordered a couple pizzas on Sunday. They were so good, we went... back on Monday! Thanks Joe (owner) and Dianna (sp?) (owner)! The garlic knots are a must! As a bonus, Papa Angelo's serves beerfrom my favorite local brewery, Broke Brewing! I don't normally choose Canadian Bacon, but it's my first choice here, withtheir special jalapenos! Read more

Great Pizza! Easy online ordering and delivery! Garlic knots are also delicious.

Pizza by the slice, salads, and more. This pizza cafe is quite large, and has pizza made to order that is worth a visit due to... its deliciousness. Some of the best New York-esque pizza in OKC/Bethany area. Food: Thin, foldable, chewy crust with greatcheese blend flavor and traditional pizza topping selection. Atmosphere: Friendly, fun road signs with novelty themeddecorations. Cost: ~$13 lunch combo pizza, drink, salad. Starts at around $8. Toppings extra. Service: Friendly, professionaland prompt. There was an issue with my to-go order that staff did not hesitate to fix over the phone. Read more

A great local favorite. Thinner pizza crust with a cracker like texture and overall reminiscent to say Sabarros. The ingredients... always taste fresh. Vegan cheese available if you?re into that. Odd hours of operation thanks to Covid-19 I?m sure. Stop induring the week for a great lunch special. Big fan of the new Reaper sauce if you want some spice in your life. R.I.P. Diablosauce. Highly recommended. Goes toe to toe with other local big guns in the pizza world, Empire and Falcones. Stop in for aslice! Now offering beer on tap as well Read more

Pricey but delicious. We discovered they have VEGAN CHEESE after we ordered. The garlic knots were great and their habanero... sauce was AMAZING! We will be back for more! Read more

If you?re looking for New York style pizza, look no further than Papa Angelo?s. We always enjoy what we order; the food is... always very fresh and delicious. The atmosphere is a fun tribute to NYC. Read more