Reviews for Marcello’s Italian Ristorante in Berkeley Heights, NJ

We were here for a party. Everything was average but the portions were large. The wait staff was attentive and the restaurant... was clean. Read more

Waiter was extremely rude to our children. Salad wasn?t washed. Waiter rude to us. And oh, there?s a hidden 15% markup on all... items. The prices on the menu are not the prices they charge you. When you get the bill, prices are 15% higher. Waiter saidthere was a 8x11 paper on the table, that no one saw, with a note on the bottom that said 15% charge. What a crock. Totally badtaste. They should AT LEAST put a note conspicuously on every menu page stating that. Very shady place. Read more

Marchellos has the best Italian food and mussels. I love there cupachinno its delicious. I moved to Barnegat nj and the... ride is worth it. Love his service. The gentleman Luis that always serves us is the best!!! Thank you Marchello ????. Mybrother from keywest loves there food too. Read more

Fresh food, and an attention to detail. This is the old style Italian dining that I grew up with. Clean and has outdoor and... indoor seating Read more

This was once our family?s favorite Italian restaurant. We had many parties here in the past and enjoyed their food so much.... Recently though all it is is robbery. The taste of the food has gone down considerably yet the prices just keep going up.Service there was once very friendly and enjoyable and even that is no longer. The worse experience we had yet was tonight whenwe ordered a couple of dinners and one cheesesteak sandwich. First of all I specifically told them I wanted just steak andcheese went on to say no onions or peppers and when I got home it was loaded with onions intact when my husband tried removingthe onions we realized they didn?t put any steak on the bread at all it was an onion sandwich. Not too mention for one realdinner and a order of spaghetti and meatballs it was $55. I posted the picture of the sandwich because just reading this reviewwould not be enough to ever describe how disgusting this sub was. If your wondering why I gave 2 stars it?s only because at onetime it had given us great memories as a family. Read more

I've been hearing how great the chicken parm is here... so I had to try it... was NOT disappointed... very good... thin sliced,... tender, not overly bread crumbed and the sauce is what you'd expect from someone's grandma from Italy ... really good Read more

Excellent server, Luis, took great care of us. The food was plentiful and tasty. Prices were very reasonable for the amount... given. We will definitely return. Read more

Best outdoor set up of any restaurant I?ve been at during this Covid crisis! My wife and felt very comfortable and safe under... Marchello?s spacious canopy. I had the homemade Pork Bracciola with homemade linguini, and my wife had Fiocchi D?amoreCasalinga, delizioso!! The pizza has a perfect crust, love it! 9 times out of 10 Marchello is there, if you don?t see him, he?scooking. Making sure his customers are being taken care of. The service was very good. I highly recommend trying Marchello?s, bring your family out along with your favorite wine, you will not be disappointed! Read more