Reviews for Pizza Pirate in Benicia, CA
Good solid tasty pizza, fresh ingredients, good selection of pizza combinations with medium thick crust. Fun atmosphere for... kids, a local hangout with good customer service. Read more
Read great reviews about this place so we drove out and ordered the Walk The Plank pizza and a regular salad. The chicken is... claimed to be marinated in their creamy garlic sauce. Chicken tasted like plain unseasoned chicken. The garlic sauce was on thepie and had no garlic taste. It also said to have garlic on the topping, no garlic. The Italian sausage was flavorful and therewas no cornmeal on the bottom of the pie which was wonderful, old school pies didn't use cornmeal. They also have a servicecharge for using a credit card. Read more
1st time here. We ordered a salad with bread sticks and a medium pizza... chicken, tomato, green onion, fresh garlic, added... sausage, with a cream sauce. The salad was pretty big. The bread sticks were quite old and dried out. The pizza had noflavor. Hardly any garlic, very little sausage, and chicken was bland. Not impressed, especially for the price. We got amedium to have left overs for lunch... wish we'd got much smaller. Read more
We were invited to try this place through a letter welcoming us to the neighborhood with a coupon. Interesting offer, so why... not? The pizza made us sick to our stomachs. It felt like eating a hot and ready pizza: You know it's been sitting a while andpretty greasy. I don't think I'll be giving this place another chance any time soon. They actually sent a follow-up post cardthanking us for our visit. It was cute and sincere, and I'm sure they have a great staff, but I just won't take another risk. Read more
Slow place. Would of expected more out of the raviolis and bread twists with soda we got for around $30. Food is not too bad.... Clean place though. Could be better. By the ways what up with this all genders bathroom sign and the third person? Read more
For $35 I expected some kind of greens on a plate not a small soup bowl. The ravioli looks empty inside. The silverware is limp... plastic. It took about 45 minutes to get an order of just two items. Aaarg matey, it's all theme but no dream. Read more
Love the pizza here, it's always delicious and fills me up. This is my second time here, and it's just like I remember it. I... hope to enjoy it for many more years. Thank You for the amazing Pizza Read more
It's a homey themed pizza parlor. They've been here forever and actually keep a clean restaurant! The food and dough is made in... house. I'd recommend the personal pepperoni and or Anne Bonnie (pesto penne with cheese)* can ask for no cheese* It's fantasticand my friends and I have gone here for the past 18 years. The bathrooms are also themed and stocked with hygiene goods forbaby's to adults. There is a mini arcade that gives tickets for redemption. Read more