Reviews for Reye's Pizza in Belmar, NJ
Worst pizza I have had in years threw it away after 3 bites
Friendly staff; all portions are generous; good prices. Special Italian Cold Sub was tasty, Cheesesteak Sub too, Seafood was... fresh with linguine in good, not exceptional, red sauce. No bathroom for customers. Will try pizza soon. Read more
I ordered a pepperoni pie and it was absolutely delicious! I do not go by people's nasty reviews I myself will be the judge and... jury ???????????? Read more
I've Been there 4 times Any Slice is Delish I order the Pizza Cheese Steak Awesome.. The price is right and it's Quality.
The food was so good, very impressed how fast they were and we ordered alot. The owner is so nice.
Best pizza I?ve had, north of wildwood, and I?m fat so I know! Just drove 20 minutes out of my way to have a couple slices for... lunch. Any time I?m remotely close, this is where I come. Read more
I cant be too hard on them because it was memorial weekend but pizza was cold and they mess a simple order of chicken wings but... it was busy little joint and every one else seems to enjoy their sliced of pizza. Read more
pretty goood. ???? worth trying: italian sub meatball parm sub sausage peppers and onions sub chicken parm sub pizza