Reviews for Cafe Castello in Bellport, NY
Nick is so accommodating and his food is excellent. I haven?t eaten anywhere else since landing here in Long Island I finally... got to have real Italian cuisine. Read more
Authentic Italian made with love , Nick the owner makes you feel right at home and has a real passion for his craft that you... taste in every bite. Whether you just want a quick slice or a meal that makes me feel like your sitting in Naples, this is aplace to stop and enjoy Read more
The buffalo chicken pizza is hands down the best pizza I've ever had. That's not too say anything they make isn't good, I... seriously don't think you can choose anything bad on their menu. Even the plain cheese pizza is phenomenal! We'll be orderingfrom here from now on ???? Read more
we enjoyed the seafood deluxe what a fantastic meal. a must try for everyone. full of fresh seafood this dish fed 3 people with... leftovers. Cafe Castello never disappoints. thanks your 7pm pickup Read more
Gentlemen behind the counter was very nice and offered to make me a pepperoni roll since there was not any usually offered... there. Just thought it was very nice of him. Ive been other places and have asked for something and have been told " sorry wedont have those here." but had everything to do it. Read more
Wonderful little Family Italian restaurant in the quiet little town of Bellport. Ate in back dining room...very comfortable and... airy. Our server was Sweet and took great care of us. Dinner choices were vast I got Cappelli with white clam sauce which wasexcellent. BJ got her Chicken Parm..large order and tasted great. Mussels Posillipo was nice ..lotsa plump Mussels in tastygarlic tomato sauce and for dessertwe got the Bomba, big ball of vanilla/Chocolate icecream covered with delish frozen milkchocolate. Didn't try Pizza but we will return soon and try some more dishes! Read more
Amazing local pizza place. Nick, the owner, is so friendly, and my kids love him. The pizza...amazing.
We went last night & sat outside . There was a special ?BAND? menu which we did not expect. It stated $30 min per person. Menu... gave selection of 3 appetizers, 4 entrees, & 2 desserts. No prices were listed. The four of us assumed dinner was a 3 coursemeal. We did not want appetizers but took them because included. When it came time to order dessert waitress told us we alreadyreached our $30 per person so it wasn?t necessary to order dessert! The menu was very misleading. We should have been told itwas not a 3 course meal. Food was good but we would not return because of being deceived. Foo Read more