Reviews for Matteo's in Bellmore, NY
Disappointed tonight! Ordered Eggplant Parm which was lukewarm to cold. I'm not one to return my food to the kitchen so ate it... the way it was. Would be nice if pasta was included on the side, but it's not. Stuffed mushroom appetizer was delicious.They'vediscontinued the fruit & biscotti after dinner. Fruit is now $8 & $2 per biscotti. For dessert ordered vanilla Häagen-Dazs.Served in an overly large bowl w/two very small scoops. Asked for choc syrup on top. Rec'd about 1/2 a spoonful drizzled on top.My husband's dinner was delicious & hot. Last year I ordered Chicken Parm & again came out cold. That time I had to return it.Won't be returning anytime soon. To pay the amount of money we did for this dinner, it should've been much better. Read more
Fantastic food and service. They go out of their way to make you feel welcome and their food is second to none. Highly... reconnected!! Read more
INCREDIBLE!!! Pasta Frutti di Mare is to die for ? Staff is terrific ????
Beautiful restaurant & bar. The service and the food were excellent. My family of 4 Went last night to celebrate my husband's... birthday. Their food is family style. We had a half order of fried calamari, half order of Cesar salad, full orders of pennealla vodka & chicken parm and we had enough of each to take home. They give a complimentary fruit platter with whipped cream tothe table after dinner and we ordered cappuccino & chocolate brownie alla mode. I told them it was my husband's birthday andthey brought out a slice of ice cream cake with a beautiful sparkler candle in it and sang with us too! Everything wasdelicious. We will definitely be back. It's a great place to go for a celebratory event. I wish I took pictures of the food buteverybody dug right in as soon as it was placed on the table. Read more
Visited for the first time. Family style: very large portions that you share amongst yourselves. NO pizza on the menu. Fairly... fancy place with thick, white tablecloths and napkins. Service was friendly, professional, and overall excellent. I cannotrecommend this restaurant more! Go here! Read more
?nice place ?great service ?family style dishes for 2 or 4+ ?great cocktails ???? ?definitely recommended for friends gathering... or any type of celebrations. ?everything is always fresh and just made perfect. ?seafood linguine is andante and delicious???? Thank you for having us. We ll be back ? Read more
A true classic, a taste of Italy. The service is excellent, you allows feel part of the family. The appetizers are amazing and... the entrees are enormous. A true family style restaurant, bring your friends, bring your family. This place is top notch. Anddon?t forget there fresh deserts. Giavani & Toni always make you feel part of there family, a must visit! Read more
I had my daughter baby shower there in a private room. The food was delicious, service exceptional and the ambiance was lovely.... Our waiter Francesco was Awesome, he ensure every thing went smoothly. Highly recommend here. Read more