Reviews for Scarlet Lane Brewing Beech Grove Pizza in Beech Grove, IN

The pizza is pretty good- their crust is very doughy which I love. Their service can use some work tho which is really the only... reason 3 stars is given here. I've never been able to get ahold of them by phone and the times we've ordered out, the deliveryor pick up has never been close to being on time unfortunately. Happy to adjust this rating if I'm proven wrong with futureorders! Read more

Spring Wood Slasher: pretty good, the double pepperoni makes this pizza very greasy so keep that in mind, but a paper towel will... help Audrey II: pretty good, lots of fresh veggies Overall sauce and crust are very good Online ordering was not veryfriendly. Estimated delivery was off by 30 minutes and it didn?t update often or correctly. When I tried calling the number ontheir google page they didn?t pickup. I also called a number that was listed in some of the owner comments but they didn?tpickup either. It?s good pizza, but a little overpriced. I would definitely not order online again and the customer service isseverely lacking. Read more

Great environment. Especially if you're a horror fan! The pizza was fresh and delicious, as well as the breadsticks. I loved... every bit of it. Read more

Excuse my missing slice of pizza I had to try it. I got a veggie pizza minus the bell & banana peppers. I enjoyed the pizza. I... really like the sauce, it has a nice flavor. The bread was nice and plain. I ordered garlic stix with the garlic butter, which Ididn?t care for. The garlic butter seems homemade, but just not my cup of tea next time I?ll get cheese sauce and try a handtossed pizza. I?m from Chicago, so I had to go with thin crust for my first try. Read more

Hubby says best pizza crust!!! I enjoyed the cauliflower crust and vegan cheese option. We both enjoyed our pizzas and had the... place to ourselves. Nice, friendly service. Read more

We randomly stumbled across Beech Grove Pizza Company earlier this year and soon discovered their pizzas are absolutely... delicious. I?m a big fan of a saucy pizza, and this place knows how to sauce their pizzas! Every bite is filled with a deliciousheaping mouthful of their sweet, hearty marinara pizza sauce. They?ve become our new pizza pickup for friendly gatherings orsports games this year! Read more

$40 for 3 personal pizzas and breadsticks. It?s over priced considering that there?s only like 4 bites of pizza per slice. The... crust is like 3x the size of the breadsticks. Really disappointed. Read more

This is some of the best pizza I?ve ever eaten! The Fear the Reaper was amazing, smoky, and hot! The Ron Swanson is true to its... namesake and the Smokehouse BBQ was delicious. My new favorite thing is the Cauliflower Crust. Try it, you won?t bedisappointed. It?s the pizza in the last pic. Read more