Reviews for Miss Mindy's Homemade Ice Cream in Bayville, NJ

OH MY GOODNESS!! Simply the BEST ice cream I have ever encountered! A+++

I have tried many a non-dairy ice cream and this place has hands-down the best ones! The flavors are wonderful, as are the... textures of various bases used. Thank you, Miss Mindys! Read more

Super clean and cute little shop with amazing ice cream! They have some interesting and unusual flavors to try in addition to... your standards, and there are always a few dairy free varieties in soft and hard. If you're in the neighborhood you have to tryMiss Mindy's! Read more

I loved all the flavors and the service was great even when very very busy. I had ice cream for dinner every evening when down... at the boat. Also enjoyed the vegan and no sugar added flavors. This location has always been an ice-cream spot over 20+ yearsand this one I like the best. Read more

Excellent ice cream and lots of delicious flavors. Prices are reasonable. Service is a bit slow but very pleasant and helpful.... My only complaint is they are constantly out of most flavors. Seems like they run out and don?t replace the ice cream flavorsfast enough. It takes 3 or 4 days to get an ice cream back in the counter. Read more

I have to say that Miss Mindy's ice cream is really really delicious. They have a great variety of flavors. Be prepared to wait... online in the summer months but they have enough people working, it doesn't take that long. And it's well worth it!! Read more

Ice cream was very tasty and smooth. Seemed like real quality ingredients. Nice selection of flavors and friendly and attentive... staff. Everything I could ask of a scoop shop. Update: Just visited again on Father's Day and it still deserves five stars. They were quite busy but the friendly folks behind the counter kept the line moving nicely. Ice cream was fantastic, I loved mychocolate malted shake! Read more

This place is amazing I got dairy free banana ice cream that is just perfect and I added dairy free chocolate sauce and wet... walnuts ???? it's better then store bought and its the same price if not cheaper! You can't beat this local NJ ice cream shop,they are so good!! Read more