Reviews for Sgt. Pepperoni?'s in Bayfield, WI
They made a pizza for me that wasn't on the menu! Chicken Bacon Ranch and it was incredible!!!
This review is not for the pizza or service it's about the fact that they make no effort to change their hours of operation on... Google (which is super easy to do). We were in town for a cruise and were planning pizza here after a googling pizza around.After walking 3 blocks we were welcomed with a locked door and no one in sight when their hours of operation showed open2-9...this was at 3:15. Just make a little effort! : ( Read more
Pizza was delicious, one of our faves when we come to Bayfield! Will always stop in again!
Very good large vegetable pizza. Square cut so perfect for a group. Good spread of vegetables with cheese. Sauce not too see.... Pizza was ready on time for pick up. I definitely would visit again Read more
Delicious pizza!!! The crust was consistent with the crunch to chewy ratio. There was the perfect amount of cheese, toppings and... sauce. I was very happy with the staff experience and the food. Great place to stop in. Read more
The pizza was not bad. We prefer a thinner, softer crust, but it was a little too thick and very tough. More sauce would have... been better also. Read more
Delicious pizza, I was surprised when I saw the staff tossing the dough. Most pizza places serve frozen pre-made crusts. We... ordered the double cheese, double crust, and it was pretty remarkable given the business setup. It is all to-go, there is anice little table on the deck where you can dine with family members. All-in-all, it was a surprisingly delicious pizza withgreat flavor, toppings, and quality. I will be ordering again. Read more
The Godmother's Pizza was amazing! We bought a large, ate 1/2 and ate the rest for lunch the next day. Not many eating choices... in Bayfield now that Maggie's is gone. Read more