Reviews for Kitty Mulligans Irish Pub in Bay Shore, NY
I always liked this bar. They have some tv's and bar food is pretty good. The bartenders and the staff are friendly. The bars... has many of chairs you'll always find a seat. Plenty of space for any events. It's also a good place for live music. The bar isunder new management and they're did great job. Check it out! Read more
Good drinks, live music/ band was great. The band was Lou Saxon jam band
We were there with bunch of people for the band. We ordered chicken sandwich which was burned, pretzel was dry, wings was ate... able When we were trying to order food at 9 pm they told me all sold out except 3 things that we can order. Really? It?s Fridaynight and it?s only 4 tables , food sold out already? This place needs some improvement or do something about it. Read more
Lovely Irish pub! The bartender Mary was terrific. I had a Long Island iced tea that was delicious. Everyone in our party raved... about the food. Atmosphere was comfortable. We truly enjoyed ourselves and I can't wait to go back. This pub is a must! Read more
Went to see a band play. They seated us at tables. Why would I want to sit down to see a band play? There was a very small area... to dance. High-top tables would have worked better. Well, of course, the place cleared out early. And the bartender, Elizabeth,had a terrible attitude and it was very obvious she wasn't able to keep up. She didn't have the right personality to be abartender. IMO Personality is key in that environment. Read more
Ordered lunch (take out). Well done burgers were burnt to the point of being inedible (yes I get it, it?s well done but the... burger meat shouldn?t crunch when bitten), fries were dry, the food tasted like it was cooked yesterday and thrown on grill toreheat. Salads were ok, lettuce was fresh out of the bag. Shepards pie was edible because there was no time to reorder food fromanother place. Read more
My husband and I love family owned places so we stopped here on our anniversary for food and drinks. The bartender was fantastic... and made great recommendations plus the drinks were nice and cold! The food was surprising AWESOME!! 100% recommendation forkitty Mulligans Read more
EVERYTHING we ordered was horrible, I don?t know where to start. The buffalo wrap was completely inedible because of how salty... it was. Upon closer inspection I realized it was mostly just blue cheese and sauce with very little chicken and no lettuce ortomato to cut it. The chicken tenders were way overpriced for three hard, thin strips. The shepards pie was dry and flavorless.I never thought I would describe shepards pie as dry, but here we are. I mean, at least add a packet of store bought gravy. Theworst offender was the irish stew. It was literally gray mush. I honestly thought I was given the wrong dish at first but thenrealized that the color was due to the fact that it was probably old and reheated numerous times. My dog?s Merrick wet foodlooks so much more appetizing. I?m hoping my dog won?t find the stew repugnant so that I can at least have someone eat it. Theonly dish we were able to finish was the potato soup. But that doesn?t mean it was delicious. It tasted like a potato. That?sit. Just like a potato with no seasoning or toppings. $67 later and we were left eating frozen tv dinners. Read more