Reviews for Jersey Mike's Subs in Bay Shore, NY

Employees behave like your bothering them and have a lethargic mood. Food is fresh.

As close to a neighborhood deli as you will find only MUCH larger heros...amazing.

Been going to the Bay Shore location since it opened. The quality and order accuracy has gotten steadily worse over time. Our... last order every part of the order was wrong. The Club sandwich only had turkey on it, literally nothing else. The OriginalItalian only had the meats and nothing else. The Cheese steak had the cheese put on top but not melted and had obviously lessmeat than usual. Such a shame, really like these sandwiches when they are made up to normal standards. Read more

Went Tuesday September 7th 2022 to this store. I've been coming for 2 years and this is the first time the place was filthy..... cups wrappers on tables crumbs and pieces of meat all over the floor when I brought it up they said they clean at the end ofshift. I asked to speak to the manager she was very rude.. you lost a daily customer Read more

Great customer service and the sandwiches are always fresh.

Beats Subway by a mile especially with the app and rewards points. Easy peasy and I don't even need to scan!! Just enter a... phone number. Plenty of options to choose at Jersey Mike's and the subs are delicious ???? Read more

Been going there for the last couple years, never had a bad sub, and I have had most of them. Always friendly.

Vito and Jan provided excellent customer service, they were very kind and patient. The food was delicious and the location was... very clean. Kid friendly for sure. We will definitely come back and feel so happy we decided to go to Jersey Mikes today. Highlyrecomended, specially the one in bay shore main st Read more