Reviews for Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar in Bay Shore, NY

Delicious and we had so much fresh seafood we brought it home and had it for dinner again the next night.

My wife took us out to eat at Hook and Reel. Food was great, price was reasonable compared to other Seafood restaurants. Servers... worked hard to get our orders right. I recommend The Shrimp mini boil. Price is right and delish Read more

Never will I eat here again . I asked for the sauce on the side and they gave it to me directly on the food. The food was way to... spicy so I asked for a new order . They basically rinsed off the food over cooking it and gave it back to me with food that waschewed on. The waiter stated that?s how they do it and had the audacity to have a attitude when he made the mistake in the firstplace. I didn?t want to try again so I just opted out of paying. So disappointed in the level of service at this location. Read more

Been there 3 times since they opened. Every time I've been I've had a great experience. Good is really good. Well I've only got... one selection but switched up the flavors. Oh yeah, can't forget the oysters... absolute must. Staff was very friendly and myfood came out expeditiously. Granted it was in the middle of the week, nonetheless, order was prompt. And the prices aren't thatbad. I'll continue to go back again and again. Read more

Went with my daughter to dinner here, great service, our food came super fast, Rosita was our server although she was busy she... made sure and check in with us to make sure we were okay the food was tasty, atmosphere warm and welcoming also very clean Read more

I know its a chain, but it?s consistently good food at a reasonable price. Bartender Nicole was awesome and the manager actually... came by to check on how we were doing. I love the boils and that you can mix and match depending on whatever you?re craving!Service was great. We love it here! ???????????????????????? Read more

CJ and I frequent Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood in Bayshore quite often and their service and cuisine is always excellent. The... bartender Brianna is always pleasant and ready to serve whatever your drinking pleasure is, and the Operations manager Don isquite personable and does a great job making sure everyone is taken care of and the food is hot, fresh and to their liking. Thesetting is very comfortable with lots of eye catching scenery and large screen TV's to look at while you wait for your food tocome; and speaking of food, we had the pleasure of ordering the Cajun Seafood Boil and it was delicious (this is a must order)! Needless to say, with cuisine this good and service this great, we will be back very soon! Kudos Hook & Reel Bayshore! Read more

The pros: The food taste great They give a decent amount of food The prices are fair Popular location Ample... parking Clean Professional staff Nice hangout spot with a DJ who plays the latest music The cons: The music so was loud that Icouldn?t hear my conversation at the table and we were NOT sitting near the DJ or speakers They have no ?to-go? containers forsaucy foods. They give boxes (which is fine for fries and dry foods) and plastic bags for boils and pastas. I would?ve preferreda plastic container to keep the food secure. Read more