Reviews for Fratelli Pizzeria in Bay Shore, NY
Best Italian pizza and restaurant in the town of Islip. Tasty, enjoy yummy yummy ????
Nine months since we moved to East Islip, and we finally found Fratelli after a string of disappointments. You want your... pizza's sauce to have actual personality - perspective, even - and this one does. I think this will be our pizza place. Read more
There is no place with better Italian food . John has been there for over 40 years and there is a reason ! Much better than... any high end restaurant. You owe it to yourself to atleast give it a try!!¡ Read more
First time eating food from this establishment and I ordered through Uber Eats. I was a little hesitant because of my last two... experiences ordering from two different pizzerias in Bay Shore whereas I ordered calzones and pizza. They weren' very goodexperiences and I didn't want a three-peat. I ordered two calzones, one with pepperoni and one with meatballs. Unfortunately, Ididn't get meatballs in one f the calzones and I got Italian sausages which I specifically didn't want and a largeneopolitan. Despite the error of giving me Italian sausage the calzone was really good. The calzone was packed with an evenamount of ricotta and mozzarella and just the right amount of sausage. I emphasis that as I had just ordered from anotherpizzeria a few weeks ago and the calzone was disgusting, in look and in taste. This pizza was made well and it also had ampleand equal amounts of sauce and cheese. It was flavorful. The pizza dough was baked just right and the pizza wasn't greasy orsoggy. I think the prices are competitive and actually worth it. Some places have charged $ 10 more for the same size pie. Iwould certainly order from here again and recommend it as a really good pizzeria. Read more
With the prices you would think the food is delicious and amazing. But the food is ok nothing to make a big deal over. We... ordered 2 salads and a chicken cutlet with broccoli dish and each one was $27 And change. What in the world was $27 each. I?msorry but who can afford this especially it?s a salad why the over charge for a small mediocre salad with no meat in it andhardly any dressing. This was the first time I ate here and my last. For these prices I better have some prime rib or lobster. Read more
extremely friendly owners and staff who welcome you as soon as you enter. delicious pizza brought to your table. have been there... twice so far, both great experiences. will definitely be trying other items from their menu. Read more
Great customer service, excellent food, and clean. Owners and staff are very courtious and professional. They care about their... customer's satisfaction, which is a rare find now a days. And we love the pizza! Read more
Very disappointed with this dish. We frequent Fratellis often and very satisfied. But their delivery dishes are very... disappointing. Especially when he said that I must have ordered through the ?Uber Eats? menu :( Read more