Reviews for Old Rail Tavern in Barrington, NJ
We love this place. Great drinks, cold beer and fantastic food. Erin and Malea usually are our servers and they are just the... best. Try the Old Rail and you won't be sorry!! Read more
What Old Rail has going for it is its styling. It lurches for that stripped down, exposed brick aesthetic all the way up to its... extended ceiling and neon signs. The u-bar looks original to the location and offers plenty of seating for patrons. I came into try their wings. Their menu advertised that their wings were unbreaded brined, with a handful of flavors. My party went withthe hot garlic and the honey hots. The wait wasn't that long to get them from the fryer to the bar top, which was definitely aplus. But to warn you, the sauces were fairly underwhelming. Both were pretty salt forward, with the hot garlic only containingthe vague, half-dreamt memory of buffalo. The only two notes that one could hazard was that of garlic and salt. It didn't helpthat although the wings were fried pretty well, they were hardly sauced. Otherwise, the prices for drafts were fair and thefront of house staff was on point. Both the staff and regulars crowd were very friendly -- anyone would feel welcome walking in. Read more
1st timers here. Lived here for 8 years and always wanted to try the Old Rail. Finally we did and it was great!!!! Service was... perfect. The food was great!! French dip, wings, cheesesteak, and appetizers were delicious. Food came out Hot. Definitelygoing to make this our new spot. Read more
My wife and I stopped in after house hunting in Jersey and didn't expect much. However, the food and the staff were amazing.... Over the past two years, most bartenders are miserable - not here. The lady behind the bar was helpful and happy to be there.Also, the garlic cheese curds are addicting. Read more
1st timer. Fresh cold beer and great food
948th different cheesesteak eaten in the last 4 years. A day of cheesesteaks with Amigo Dan and his New Castle Cronies. Old... Rail Tavern is decorated a lot nicer than I thought it was going to be. We got a cheesesteak with fried onions and mushrooms. We also got the Philly Special. The Philly special was the star. $18 I?m not rushing back for the Philly Special. TheCheesesteak, Amigo Dan?s half was not as good as mine. I guess we?ll call it good but inconsistent. Read more
Neat little spot for good food and drinks. Nice outside seating area. Great wings! Service was A+
Friendly staff and patrons. Sandwiches are loaded with meat and tasty. Beer cold. Lots of options. Bottles and draught. Prices... VERY reasonable. Great local pub. Read more