Reviews for American Pie Pizzeria in Barnesville, GA
I ordered a 15 inch pizza sent my kids to get it they made a 12 inch Instead and when she said she ordered a 15 inch they made... them pay for both pizza because they don't wanna waste ingredients owner's policy Ok so I call there to speak to a manager alady answered I asked about there No waste ingredient policy she states that the manager is out right now I offered to call backor for him to call me back she said she will when he comes back in town so I ask is there someone else I can speak to theowner's my dad and he's going to tell you everything I just did so the whole time you are the manager very deceitful then thepizza wasn't even good more dough then sauce and cheese the pizza looked like a 12 inch put in a big box Read more
We enjoy coming to this American Pie in Barnesville. The staff has always been friendly & easy to talk to. They do a great job... keeping the restaurant clean & tidy. And the pizzas are really good. Read more
This place has the best pizza ive ever had. They have got the receipe down pat. The only suggestion i would make is there is... never anyone in charge or the overwhelming first impression is that this is run by teenagers. They are very polite so pleasedont get me wrong but the sense of urgency isnt on the top of the list. Also pricewise its a little high. But you forget allthat when you eat that delicious pizza!! Read more
It's okay. You're basic pizza bar. Nothing that great. They could do a lot more on the pizza bar like include a salad bar. They... could also do more pasta. The chicken Alfredo is good but that's about all the pasta they have. Read more
I drive 30 minutes to get this pizza and never regret it. Hands down the best pizza and best local pizzeria in the area. I... honestly compare it closest to the pies I got in NY years ago, and it holds up well. All that, and it's not overpriced comparedto chains and definitely most local pizzeria. They even still have a buffet which is a miracle in these times and blows thecomparables out the water. They did seemingly change a recipe on their Butterballs recently and I feel the previous iterationwas more natural as compared to the new one, but it still doesn't detract from them. Read more
Food is decent. Not a ton of options in the area. My husband and his friends like it. I?d probably like it more if they paid... attention in the kitchen... Ordering something vegetarian (veggie wrap or asking specifically for no bacon on my pizza)apparently means sprinkle ALL the bacon on my food. 2/3 visits this has happened to me. I?m reaching my limit. Not to mentionduring this last visit my wrap came out 13 minutes after my husbands pizza? I had to check to see if they forgot to make it. Read more
Great family atmosphere! The prices are affordable and the pizza is great! The customer service is outstanding.
The food here is good. It is difficult to do call-in at times because employees will not answer phone. One other thing that... you have to watch for is there our of operation. They seem to be constantly changing them for whatever reaon. Read more