Reviews for Casey's in Baldwin City, KS
They can't make pizza to save their lives. Everytime we order a supreme it's raw in the middle. The crust in the middle ends... up like a wet papertowel. They never put all the ingredients on it. Ordered the new Brisket pizza twice now and they neverput jalapenos on it. The last time it didn't have the onions on it either. The supreme we ordered had over 1 inch of crustwith nothing on it. It sure doesn't look like the store photos. The company won't do a thing because they can't get anyoneto work there. That's why they are closed randomly. No one to work. Too bad it the only pizza option other than pizza hut inthis town. I would drive on to Lawrence or Gardner. Read more
We were in Baldwin City visiting for 4 days and I went to this Casey's about 5 times for coffee/donut/soda/gas and what not.... Each visit was just as it should have been. The staff were friendly and welcoming. Read more
I attempted to visit the Baldwin location twice in four days and both times they were closed during their posted hours. Once at... 10:42 pm and again at 10:35 pm a couple days later. I understand potentially closing early from time to time if something hascome up. Maybe their short staffed or there was an emergency, but I don?t think this was the situation. I saw employees in thestore. I would love to give you my business in the future but I?m not sure you?ll be open. Read more
Cashier made comment about how fattening M&Ms I was buying. I am 8 months pregnant and found it very rude. There was no reason... to comment on my weight nor what I was buying. Read more
I love this place and I am so happy we have one close by, but there really needs to be a more reliable way to order food. I... couldn't order online so I tried to call, which had worked in the past. But now the phone isn't working either. I tried to letthe man behind the counter (tall guy black hair) know that the line was not working but he seemed to be more involved in puttingchange in the drawer than to actually listen to me. Like I said, I love the food, but please, please make it easier to get it! Read more
They. Were. SLAMMED. I was in around 1pm today with my husband, and they did great seeing as how everybody and their mother was... there with us. For being a brand new store, as in just opened yesterday, they're doing fantastic! The other people complainingare fussing about things Casey's can't control. Get over yourselves, peeps. It's a gas station. Read more
What a fine establishment. Went for the grand opening and had a lovely experience. Breakfast pizza and donuts smack at 5:30 in... the morning???? Read more
Most of the time it?s good. The other times you never know if they will be open. If they are will they have breakfast... sandwiches, evening pizza or try and get gas put pump said decline. Look around and see everyone else not getting gas either.Let people know instead of looking out and laughing at people trying to get gas and having to go somewhere else. Read more