Menu for Gemelli Fine Foods in Babylon, NY

Ordered a hero with Fresh Mozzarella, Prosciutto, Pesto and Tomato. When I got home and looked at the hero, I was given rolled... mozzarella cheese that had prosciutto in it. I am asuuming the counter guy was lazy and did not want to cut the prosciutto.. Iwould never expect this from a well known italian pork store. Maybe if I ordered this sandwich in a jewish deli I would haveexpected this. Before this happened I actually considered this place to cater an event...NO THANK YOU! Read more

Before I visit transplanted family upstate, I always need to stock up at Gemellis.

Wanted to give it a 4. The photos and reviews looked so good so we decided to stop here to get lunch on our way to the beach. ... Huge portions and delicious sandwich but the service was ridiculously slow. No joke, probably waited 20+ minutes to have 2sandwiches made. There was no line. It was just the speed at which the sandwiches were made was shocking LOL. Not typical forthe northeast. Read more

It had been at least 10 years since I shopped here because I no longer live near by but I found myself in Babylon and decided to... bring some things home. This place has definitely changed and not for the better. The ?fresh mozzarella? had apparently beenrefrigerated. They squashed my rice balls into a container and I found 2 of the 4 broken. They were out of Italian bread and itwas 3 pm on a Saturday! But perhaps the worst part was the staff - unfriendly, disinterested and rude. This is not what youexpect in a ?specialty? store. Very disappointing. Don?t waste your time?and money. Read more

Sandwich was good. But honestly. The way earring guy treated us. Was honestly disgusting. I found out they had Garlic bread. I... asked earring guy for that he?s like no. I?m like. O ok. He?s snapped back and goes. Your sandwich is already made. Ok. Thanksfor the quality customer service. Wanted to come back. Def not now. And my girlfriends sand which was missing lettuce andtomato. And put cheese on which she didn?t want. Cuz she is lactose intolerant. I should?ve told earring guy that. But if hedidn?t care enough about the garlic bread. Imma not care about this. Cuz he would?ve just said sand which already made like hedid with me. O best part icing on cake he slammed the hero?s on the counter. Thanks bro. Maybe you shouldn?t have. So manyearrings maybe you?d be nicer. Edit: changed review to one star. Because owner clearly saw this review. Because he responded toanother one literally hours after this was posted. Glad to see customer service is key here. Read more