Reviews for Papa Nicky's Pizza in Aurora, CO
All of the staff was rude AND it was very dirty inside. Saw flies crawling all over the place, and possibly something....else... *cough* roach *cough* crawling on the floor under the counter tops. I was just picking up someone else's order and it took themover 20 mins from when I arrived to realize they didn't have what they needed to complete the order and could I call thecustomer to ask what they want instead. All with attitude like I had messed something up. Order ended up being canceled and Iran out of there. 1000/10 will not order from them ever. It was seriously yucky inside. Read more
Still not sure what to think about this place. The pizza is really good. We found them because they say they are open from 4pm... to 5am. Ordered a pizza at 130am one night for delivery and at 215 I call and they were closed. They made it right the nextevening but are usually closed well before 5am. Read more
After waiting an additional 25 minutes for delivery with Doordash. Driver spoke no English, went to totally wrong hotel. After... several texts and calls we finally got our food . Over $50 for our order nothing was warm. Mushrooms were cold, wings were cold,pizza was yes you guessed it, cold as well and crust was hard. This was first time using Doordash and I'm not impressed at alland probably never use it again after tonight. Read more
I don't know what is the deal with this restaurant, they have very good food but they always screw up someones order or the food... completely and make it not worth the money they spend there. I have only ordered from here 2 times and both times my order wasnot what I expected. The first time I ordered was from doordash and I got someone elses order and it wasn't even close to what Iordered and it wasn't anything that I even eat so I couldn't eat it, luckily since it was so late I couldn't get my orderreplaced that I did receive a full refund. That was the only reason that I reconsidered ordering from here a second time, Butthe second time I ordered from doordash again and my food was poorly packaged with my fried zucchini it was so hot still thatthe side of ranch I requested was placed inside of there the lid was steamed off that it spilled all over the zucchini and madeit all soggy and I could barely eat it because it was falling all apart. Then the French fries where so overcooked and hard withmy cold sub sandwiches that I ordered made them soggy as well. The food was cooked and prepared and packaged poorly andcarelessly. It was not worth spending $54 for and I requested a refund and doordash would not help me in any type of way forthis order. I am very disappointed and I do not think me or my family will order from here again. Read more
Burnt crusts, under cooked/pink wings, soggy/under cooked breading on zucchini and mushrooms with hard as a rock zucchini.... Supposed to be a celebration dinner, sure wasn’t much to celebrate with this food! Wasted $70+ that I definitely didn’t haveto waste! Read more
I have no idea why this place gets bad reviews. I have not had one bad experience here. Dilip is always nice to me and gives me... an amazing product and always takes care of me. The supremes pizza is amazing, the under carriage of the pizza is great, it’sa good crust so the topping doesn’t fall off. It’s right around the corner from my place and I always have fresh food. Iwill continue to order for this place and support this local business. They always ask me how the food is every time I come inand chat with me for a few as well. Tons of options on their menu and the prices you can’t beat! Read more
I placed my order over the phone, I’m not sure as to who took my order for my pizza and wings. I waited about an hour for it... to show up, then when the driver/delivery guy comes up he forgets my soda in the car. The person taking my order is talking sofast I can barely comprehend what they’re saying to me, by the time I hear my total he hangs up on me before I’m even ableto ask my last question. And to top all of that off he brings me this smashed pizza then proceeded to say “oh thank you forthe generous tip” but doesn’t give me my receipt all I know is my debit card is charged $50 for something that wasoriginally supposed to be 30$ Read more
I ordered the pizza was burnt I called first was told I didn't order from them called back they made me another one said they'd... have a pizza out to me in 30 minutes they did the driver rang my bell two times I was coming down to answer the door he wasalready getting back in his car it was just 2 minutes not even and he busted our doorbell and I called to tell them and thegentleman hung up on me had hung up on me prior to that my roommate called and he hung up on her told her you know what to do soI wouldn't order from them not professional at all Read more