Reviews for Lisa's Pie Shop in Atlanta, IN
Lisa?s pies are so good. We get thanksgiving pies from here each year & everyone loves them. Apple, Dutch apple, sugar cream,... pumpkin and rhubarb are all DELICIOUS! Read more
We stopped, hoping to buy a rhubarb pie. We were not disappointed. Pies were excellent and delicious.
Not appetizing smelling smoke and nicotine Maybe new employees are making the pies sometimes that's why they're not consistent... in ways Cinnamon rolls should remain $2 or even 1.50 when they're not fresh out of the oven No shame in day old sales manyplaces do that they bring the price down and tell the truth I love the thick crust pies ???????? But sorry I won't go therenow I don't trust a place that smells like smoke its not cleanliness I understand the masks if anybody's compromised they havea right to say what happens in their establishment regarding public entrance even if nobody's compromised Read more
Great home made pies and cakes. Found it by accident but am glad I did
The pie's were amazingly great, however the service was not!! My wife and I stopped by on 14 July 2022 because I am from Indiana... and I wanted a sugar cream pie which I can't get in Georgia where I now live and I also wanted a strawberry rhubarb pie as well.They are still requiring mask be worn in their store which was ridiculous to me, but the lady at the counter was very rude to mywife. My only complaint is that they were not friendly otherwise I would have given them five stars. Read more
The pies are amazing, well worth the money and the drive. The shop smells awesome when you walk in. It was great to see cars... lining up in the lot before she had even opened. Would recommend Lisa's to anyone. Read more
My wonderful realtor, Liz Marks-Strauss, introduced me to Lisa's Pie Shop... and I'm glad she did. Over time I've had Cherry,... Dutch Apple, and Strawberry Rhubarb. Each and every one has been delicious. I'd recommend Lisa's Pies without reservation foranyone who enjoys really good pies, or is looking for a tasty dessert option as gifts or bring to a holiday gathering... or forbreakfast with coffee or tea. Read more
We stopped at Lisa's and picked up a cherry and peach pie. They were quite tasty and stayed fresh for a long time. ????