Reviews for Nancy's Chicago Pizza - Midtown in Atlanta, GA

I love Chicago style pizza, and I'm delighted to have an option here in Atlanta. I'm a regular, and I've always been pleased. On... a recent visit, they were under-staffed and overwhelmed, and they still managed to treat me like a king. This is great foodserved by great people. I'm a fan. Go hungry; this is not a place to eat light. And remember that Chicago style is thick ... soit takes a little longer. It's worth the wait. Read more

Sheila was absolutely amazing!!! We drove an hour and a half to get to nancy's. We called ahead to make sure that there was no... wait for seating and when they told us that we could call 30 minutes before our arrival time and that our pizza which was aChicago style pizza deep dish would be ready and at our table when we arrived we did that and we did not have to wait. Theservice was absolutely incredible, every need was taken care of! Our tea stayed full and the ranch and the marinara was soawesome!! I highly recommend and it was well worth the drive and we will start to do this on a more regular basis and Pizza Hut,Domino's, Papa John's and Little Caesars do not even compare or are in the same League!! Read more

Omg!!! I love pizza it?s one of my favorite foods and I have been looking for a pizza place in the city to visit. When I say I... hit the jackpot with this one. The pizza and cheese sticks are so bomb omg the garlic sauce that came with them is so good I?venever had that kind before but it was great. Our server was Jenny she was super nice and amazing I def had to tip her so if youall get Jenny please tip her she?s amazing that?s who I?m going to ask for whenever I go back. This place was great will be backagain & again lol. If you guys didn?t notice, the Nancy sign changes colors that?s so cool get a nice picture I have plenty???? Read more

10/10 boneless wings. Absolutely loved. The pizza was alright. Nothing special, but still not bad. I did not like the Cesar... salad at all, which normally is a safe bet for me. Garlic bread was alright, but I didn?t care for the sauce to dip it in Read more

Was actually really presently surprised with Nancy?s! Took advantage of an Uber Eats deal that was BOGO stuffed crust personals... and also had a thin crust mushroom pizza. I will say our Uber Eats experience was rather annoying as despite the order marked?ready to pick up!? we still had to wait 20 mins or so. Other than that, staff greeted you immediately upon walking in and werecourteous. Inside was kind of depressing, though, quite empty and bar was seemingly out of commission. Takeout joint for us! Interms of the goodies- one of our stuffed crust had busted open and quite literally all of the cheese had poured out which waskind of a bust but the other stayed in tact. Was comparable with real Chicago style pizza I?ve tried in Chicago! Fluffy butteryand sauce was on point. The thin crust wasn?t really thin but I guess in comparison makes sense. I loved how they cut into bitesize pieces! Good flavor all around and mushrooms were delicious (but somewhat sparse). I do think it?s over priced for thesizes but the quality was up to par. Not the NY style pizza I know and love but definitely something worth trying and probablythe most memorable pizza I?ve had in ATL. Read more

Good Chicago style pizza, deep dish. Tasty and delicious. We also shared a bowl of salad and chicken wings. Delicious. Friendly... service. Read more

Simply one of the best pizza?s in the town! We took veggie thin crust pizza which is equal to regular crust pizza in general if... we get from some other place and garlic bread. Their 2-3 serving pizza was huge and we(2 people) couldn?t finish it off. Thegarlic bread came with marinara sauce and pesto sauce which was delicious. Both items were delicious but it seemed bit expensiveto me. I?ll recommend this place! Read more

Really great pizza! Got the thin crust instead of the deep dish, which was around the same thickness as a regular pizza.... Mozzarella sticks with marinara were also bomb. They even had the marinara heated up, nice touch ???? Read more