Reviews for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Arlington in Arlington, TX

I have a sweet tooth that is beyond compare. I was within a few blocks of Buttermilk Sky Pie and they came up as the closest... bakery in my search. That was an awesome stroke of luck. When I entered the store I was greeted warmly and shown the variousselections available. It took me about four days to come back. In just a few days I have sent them three customers, one ofwhich has also repeated. Buttermilk Sky Pie is well worth the money as there is no substitute for the very best quality! Read more

I?ve been home sick with the flu and suddenly got a sweet tooth, and the coconut cream pie sounded perfect. I got the 4 stack to... round out the purchase and to share with friends next week. Super cute packaging, personalized note, and the coconut pie wasgood. What would have made it even better was it not being so danged sweet! My pallet kept looking for some relief, either inthe meringue or in the crust, but I could find nothing to balance the overly-sweet taste! It had promise, it still does! I seeI?m not the only one who has had the same experience. Hopefully these reviews will prompt a slight tweak on what could be anamazing little pie! Read more

Love Caroline and BSP! Their pies are so delicious and the staff always has something funny and uplifting to say. A great local... spot to spend your dollars and get something delicious in return! Read more

I?m sad to admit this out loud, but I come here every weekday and get a small peanut butter pie. They are insanely good!!!? The... ladies that work here are every bit as sweet as the pies they make. Definitely worth a stop. Read more

Visited this gem for the first time, I got the southern buttermilk and the strawberry pie. They were both tasty and I especially... liked that they both weren't too sweet! I was immediately greeted upon entry and was taken care of quickly! Read more

Ordered via DoorDash. Reasonable prices and I had a sweet tooth. A kind note was attached to my order which was packaged to... perfection. Many different flavors to choose from. I?m a big chocolate chip cookie fan so i ordered 2 of those (mini) peanutbutter/oreo and coconut cream pie for a total of 4 minis. i was disappointed with the choc chip mini?s very dry and crummy.peanut butter/oreo mini had to be my favorite very moist and yummy. coconut cream mini was rather sweet in my opinion but stillgood. I?d still recommend this place. Read more

Their pies are actually super good! Their packaging is super sweet and thoughtful. Their pies, especially their chocolate cream... pie, are all really good. However the coconut cream pie was a bit too sweet for my taste, felt like it gave me diabetes. But thecream on it was delicious though. The chocolate chewy pie, the one with the cookie in the middle, was a bit dry and crumbly. Iliked how the cookie tasted, but the crust around it made it feel dry, maybe if there was some cream for balance? Overall it?sgreat and reasonably priced. Will definitely be back for their chocolate servings! Read more

Cute pie shop. The chocolate cream pie was good, the coconut cream was a bit too sweet according to three of my friends that... tried it. My son like the cookie pie but than again, he eats anything sweet. Not totally sure I'd go out of my way to get morebut if in the area, and craving pie I could buy again. Prices are reasonable. Read more