Reviews for The Mad Apple Burger & Billiard Co. in Appleton, WI

First time visiting this establishment, was kind of empty at first but seemed to fill up as time passed. Menu was extensive but... no childrens menu. The meals we ordered were cooked precisely as asked. The food was surprisingly flavorful and enjoyable. Myson's meal was not very child friendly. A few burnt fries on a plate with 3 huge fried chicken paddies which were supposed to bechicken tenders. The beers we ordered were awkwardly arranged. When you order a blue moon an orange wedge goes with it, not blueberries. Lastly the wait staff is a bit robotic, nice but but not very friendly. I felt like I was ordering from an AI ratherthan a human person. This place is worth a second visit because the adult meals were that good. A few tweaks and thisestablishment could be a fabulous five star restaurant. Read more

Service was friendly and welcoming. The food good and came out quickly. We ordered cheese curds, and two different burgers.... Burgers and fries were excellent. Cheese curds were extremely salty. Read more

The Mad Apple Burger & Billiard Co. has a big customizable burger menu. We, however, went with the standard Mad Apple Burger... which is a Western burger with onion rings and BBQ sauce. The toppings, including lovely long stips of bacon, were very good. The flavors were fine. It was the standard beef burger patty that was a let down. It didn't feel hand made and was not thickenough. That's probably why I didn't get the medium rare that I ordered. Instead, my burger was served medium well. So, paythe additional $3 to choose a different meat. I'm thinking elk will provide a thicker and juicier burger while tasting closerto beef than the other choices. The hand cut fries were cut thin, so they were crispier than usual. Good idea. The cheesecurds were only okay because they were clumped together which made some of them hold too much oil. The staff was very friendlyand attentive. The place itself is pretty huge and impressive, and outside seating is available. Plus, there's a ginormouspool hall in the back with professional style billiards. There are other games to play as well. So, overall, it's a cool placeto hustle up a game and some grub. Read more

Don't give a lot of 5 star reviews but this place absolutely deserves it from service to menu options to food quality i had an... outstanding experience Read more

Not "giant" wings but pretty meaty. Over did the cyanne pepper on one side of the wings but very tasty otherwise .I Recommend... the bacon wraps!!! Bar Pretty pricey $$$ on alcohol. Server Pamela was excellent and pretty knowledgeable about the area . Read more

Seemed like a great place to go to, but drinks were nasty, especially the bloodies, we watched a few others leave theirs at the... table. Asked for a steak done medium... This is what I got, and the middle was purple still. They basically threw it on a flattop until it turned brown on the sides and called it good. People behind us had the same problem. My fiance got a chicken wrapand said it had no flavor and the chicken was soggy. We got there at 6pm and didn't get our food until 7pm. Understand thattimes are rough and staff is short, but there wasn't even a manager available And our waitress did not even listen when we triedto ask about having my steak cooked a bit longer. She literally shrugged and walked away. Super cool pool hall though. Read more

The menu here is great and had a lot of very unique options. However, it seemed execution was lacking a bit. Our burger was far... overcooked and the mac n cheese on top was very dry. The pulled pork/Mexican street corn quesadilla was lacking flavor a bit.Both items seemed as if maybe there was new staff? Don't get me wrong the food was good, and we would try again! It just seemslike they are just slightly missing the mark on being excellent. Read more

We have had good service on multiple visits and nearly perfect food. We love the freshness of the food obtained as locally as... possible.... pleased with the salad choices. The yellow fin tuna with pesto dressing is excellent as well as the chicken baconranch salad. Four stars only because perfection is rare. Wish I could do 4.5 tho... Read more