Reviews for Mattina's Pizzeria in Amherst, NY
Really good. Great value for 26$ Been very consistent lately which is hard to come by these days. Perfect amount of sauce and... cheese. Look at that Cheese Frico on it too! excellent work! Read more
The guys working there taking orders, ringing out, and making the pizza are super friendly. I ordered extra cheese and was very... happy to actually get it! The cup and char pepperoni was yummy too! The sauce was a bit too sweet for me and it was a littlewell done, but all and all it was really good and I had 2 slices. Read more
If I could give 0 ZERO stars I would!!!! Ordered cheese and pepperoni pizza for takeout. I was disappointed and disgusted at... the state of that pie. It was inedible. There was way to much sauce and cheese on the pizza. It slimy, the cheese spilledover the pie, but not in a good way. It was burned the tasted bad. The sauce tasted like ketchup, some might like a sweetsauce. I couldn?t really tell if it was the burnt cheese that made taste so bad, or if the sauce was foul. Would not recommendthis pizzeria to my worst enemy. Read more
I know lunch time is busy, but I think a picture speaks a thousand words. Bought a half pizza, it was nice and fresh. Very good... and tasty. Read more
Large cheese, Extra sauce, well done is perfection. Grew up eating the other location on Delaware and I?m happy to report this... one is just as consistent and delicious. Great Buffalo style pie. Read more
I got a pizza here last night, 7/15, and it gets 5 starts for how yummy it looked!! Unfortunately, that?s all it had going it... for it. Seems to really lack seasoning? taste wasn?t all there?. And there was a black hair on my pizza that didn?t belong toanyone in my house?. Which turned me off and I couldn?t eat anymore ?????. I get it that that can happen, but was quitedisappointed. Read more
Ordered the Wednesday special, a large pizza and 24 wings for $40.99. The pizza was cooked just right, the sauce was sweet, the... dough was a nice consistency, and the cheese was right up to the crust. The wings were nothing special, typical pizza jointwings, but I would definitely come back for the pizza. Read more
Have been a regular customer for years. We ordered at least every 2 weeks if not more. Went in to pick up 2 trays for a... community project we hold every year. This year I asked for the manager and a young kid said he was in charge I asked if therewas anything he could do for this project and he said why would he when he can sell these all day long. I would have been coolwith him if he said it was against their policy, but he didn't. He proceeded to tell me he didn't care. As I gave him my creditcard I told him I would remember this the next time I ordered. He then told me he didn't care as he doesn't need my business. To think I supported them through COVID when they needed me and know they don't care. I went back to our community servicewhere we feed up to 60 families for Thanksgiving and told the other members how I was treated. So now we will be boycottingMartina's for a long time not because they didn't help but because of this kids poor attitude and not caring about losing a verygood customer. Read more