Reviews for Jersey Mike's Subs in Amherst, NY

Jersey mikes is amazing !! This location specifically is super friendly and take their time to put love into our meals ! They... all greeted us at the door and made us feel happy to be there . Read more

Food was on the Money, staff was super friendly! Would consider using them for catering. As a pharma rep I cater about 4-5... lunches a week. One of the most worrisome things is using a new restaurant for catering, you always worry about the customer notliking the food. I was so impressed with my experience I think I am going to give these guys a shot! Read more

Used online ordering and still had to wait about 10 -15 minutes after pick up time and it was NOT busy. When we arrived home 2... of the 3 subs were wrong, not worth going back to correct and WILL NOT be going back again, save the money and go somewherewhere the employees care! Read more

Friendly and informative staff. The subs taste great, Reasonable prices. The ingredients taste fresh. The rosemary parm bread is... fantastic. Read more

Paid 2 dollars and 19 cent for extra bacon and sub only had 2 pieces of bacon on it so it would seem the sub only comes with 1... piece of bacon. Well don't think I will be ordering from them again. It's sad becuase I have built up 8,900 points and don'tuse them and have always paid. Looks like I will no longer be getting any more points at lest from this location or owner. Read more

Disappointed with size. Ordered 3 regulars States in ad that regulars feed 2 people .Not! Spent over $30. All subs were fresh... but small amount of meat. Will not order again. Can get whole subs at other places for same quality and price. Just a bunch ofhype! Read more

Subs are so delicious. Frustrates the hell out of me that I order ahead on the app, show up at the pick up time, and still have... to wait 10 minutes for them to finish. It?s a bit expensive but the food is worth the price. The service? Not so worth it Read more

I had a coupon and used it just to see how it was. Honestly great food and nice place when I went to pick it up. Everyone else... was friendly and helped me find my order. Read more