Reviews for Anchor Bar in Amherst, NY
Original Buffalo secret sauce-1 bottle of franks, 1 stick of butter, 1 package of good seasons mix. Food is good. 5 stars for... the Nostalgia. Read more
Honey bourbon bbq boneless wings were delicious. Tequila shots were good and Long Island iced tea was good. Definitely got my... buzz. Britney and Gabby at the bar were really nice and friendly. Great service last night and great atmosphere. Thanksladies!!! Went back to Anchor Bar last night for one last hang out before I head back to Virginia. Britney was a darling. Greatservice, great drinks, great wings, perfect company, gonna be visiting again when I’m in town. Gabby and Britney, y’allrock!!! Read more
My daughter is now in UB, and this is our favorite spot to eat when we’re in the neighborhood. Friendly staff, reasonable... prices, great food, and their piña colada slush became a favorite of mine. Read more
Tldr: go literally anywhere else. Story is, the family came here for dinner. Very nice waitress, and hostess. Would say the... staff was great 10/10. The food negative 10/10. Kids Mac and cheese was overdone noodles in a queso sauce with shredded cheeseon top. Wife's didn't enjoy the burger, I don't recall the reason but she didn't finish half. My food was pictured. Here is thesize of the chicken with a beer next to it. should say slider and not sandwich for th 15.99 I paid and a side was another 4.99.The chicken was good but the burger was a mess. Ordered bbq sauce but it was dunked in both buffalo sauce and bbq sauce. The bunwas soggy from buffalo sauce. Then I got coleslaw, and it was grey with about 1/2 inch of grey water on the bottom, hope Idon't get sick. Like how do you mess this up. Ordered kids food early to get them fed right away but they just brought it allout the same. we told them to get that first. Anyways, $85 for 2 beers, 2 adult dinners and 2 kids meals. Hard pass in thepermanent future. Read more
Amazing wings! My husband and I came with our dog, and they immediately brought out a bowl of water for him. We got half buffalo... wings, half BBQ wings, and they were both delicious! Read more
Casual dining, lots of choices for all your picky friends. Always able to just walk in with no reservation. Great place in the... summer to enjoy car cruise nights. (Usually Thursday evenings) Read more
Food was just not good at all. We were expecting great buffalo wings as Anchor Bar is supposed to be home on the buffalo wing,... unfortunately what we got were like these Dollar Tree store microwave style flavorless wings. The "chicken strips" were morelike chicken nuggets from McDonald's, they even had air pockets in them. They were definitely not whole chicken breast but morelike a compressed meat product. The drinks were not even good. We should have left after asking the waiter what he thought ofthe food, because he couldn't really give an answer other than he hadn't really tried much on the menu. That answer is usually ahuge red flag. I chose to give a very low tip due to the waiter's lack of knowledge and when he finally brought our check, heplaced it on the table with no pen. I had to ask another server for something to write with so that I could sign my tab. And nothe place was not busy at all during the time we were there. If I could give a negative star review Anchor Bar would be thefirst. I would not be able to recommend this place and I would never return here. Read more
Food was overdone. The wings were insanely crunchy and dry and the sauce could not save them. Husband got the buffalo pizza... which was about 90% Bleu cheese and practically no buffalo sauce, he is typically a garbage disposal and leaves nothing to wasteand ended up stopping a couple slices in because it was too much. Server barely showed up, no wet naps, honestly for the hypeits ehhhhhh. I'd stick to the wing place you normally frequent. Read more