Reviews for Fudgy's Ice Cream in Amenia, NY
One of the best roadside ice cream stops in the North East.
super delicious, I had a brownie sundae and it even had a massive brownie at the bottom
Ice cream is delicious. I had two scoops of Peanut S?mores and my friend had one scoop Peanut s?mores and one scoop pistachio.... Staff was friendly. Read more
Great Ice Cream!!!! Prices are very good and the amount of ice cream they give is fantastic. A kid size is like a medium... anywhere else you would go. We had 12 in our group and the total was only $22.00 Read more
Great unique ice cream selection. It was so good! Banananna split recommended!
Nice place. Cash only. A little overpriced but still nice. There are lot of flavors to choose from, even more than in the... picture. I got Perry' Ice Cream banana cream pie in a waffle cone. If you want to sit, there are tables to the right of thebuilding. Lots of parking in the front. Not to far from the Harlem Valley Rail Trail. Read more
Convenient location, but overpriced in relation to quality (a medium shake costs as much as a whole pint of Häagen Dazs).... Though Fudgy?s is surrounded by local creameries, the ice cream is Perry?s, sourced from Pennsylvania. Around twenty differentflavors, served hard, soft and milk-shaked. Napkins issued only upon request. Staff all young trainees. One saving grace is thatFudgy?s contributed to events at the local school, so that civic engagement is appreciated. Gravelled parking lot deeply pitted,so be careful when entering and exiting. There are two picnic tables for those who prefer not to drip melting ice cream intotheir laps in the car. Read more
Great ice cream, nice summertime treat