Reviews for The Lobster Roll Amagansett in Amagansett, NY
Here on the Island for a long girls weekend and on our way back from the Montauk Lighthouse on a VERY chilly weekend and on the... hunt for something to warm us up. We spotted The Lobster Roll and decided this was the place. We were NOT disappointed!! Thelobster bisque, clam chowder and grilled cheese we ordered really hot the spot and warmed us right up. The service was greatand the food was delicious. I would 100% visit again if I was ever in the area and highly recommend you go if you?re lookingfor some thing quick, affordable and yummy!! Read more
Not a big see-food fan. Stopped by this place because of the large crowd. We tried fried shrimp and a lobster roll, and it was... good. The $80 bill for two people's small-portion lunch gave me a jolt. Read more
The place to be for Lobster rolls. Served in either the traditional or hot lobster, you can?t go wrong. The clam chowder and... fish and chips were really good as well. Really nice setting and service as well. Highly recommend this place. Read more
Servers are friendly and the menu is extensive. Highly recommend the hot lobster roll, though the traditional cold one is solid... as well. Onion rings are very oily, so I'd suggest skipping them. Tip: this place is busiest when it first opens, so go for alater lunch or dinner. Nice outdoor space with flowers to help the space feel cozy. Read more
Loved it. Arrived at 2:30 on Saturday for a 15-minute wait. Service was as-expected for the scene. There?s a bar window for... anyone waiting to be seated?no hassle to find a gap at the bar. The food was solid for the scene. Ideal for groups of 2-6. Read more
I got a burger & fries. Burger was pretty bland & the bun was cold. For a burger fries & draft beer I paid $24 so not bad prices... at all. Very cute restaurant. Good vibes and ambiance. Great service. Plenty of paeking. I will definitely return. Read more
Looking for that quintessential I am on vacation meal? Lobsters, sweet corn, clams? It just did not get any better than coming... to the Lobster Roll, an icon welcoming your arrival to Montauk. Menu choices are everything seafood plus a few grilled types ofmeat for land lovers. Additionally, they have express orders for quartz of soups and takeout too. And they have many healthysalads and add on's too. For those concerned about health issues, they sanitize, wear masks, and appear exceptional in payingattention. They also have both indoor and covered outdoor seating. And if you opt for the Clams Casino, save the dish and pourthe bacon flavors garlic butter over your sweet corn and lobster or baked potato. My superb waitress tipped me off. The tastewas just out of this world! Enjoy! Read more
Best lobster roll we tried on our trip through NY, Mass, and Maine - so that?s saying something. Their hot lobster roll can?t be... beat! Paired with Hearty Manhattan Chowder is *chef?s kiss*. Only thing we didn?t enjoy were the buffalo calamari. I think wejust enjoy calamari prepared the southern, calabash way. Don?t miss a stop in here. They are also dog friendly! Read more